Search This Blog

Showing posts sorted by relevance for query experian. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query experian. Sort by date Show all posts

Friday, August 18, 2006

Experian Denies My Right to Dispute Credit Report Problem

Why Is Experian So Elusive?


In my last post on August 9, “Level of Competence at Experian Credit Bureau Found to Be Low,” I was unable to get my credit report from Experian’s Credit Manager, where I have been a member for over twenty-five years, paying $90 annually for the service. After hours on the Internet and telephone with Credit Manager personnel who turned out to be completely useless—and being regularly “escalated” to the “right” people—I finally reached a supervisor who was known as…the Escalation Manager.

Mark sounded competent, acted like he wanted to help, and spent another hour covering the same material as the “useless” bunch. I was wrong. He couldn’t help me, even if he wanted to. Something was also blocking Mark—the Credit Manager Escalation Manager, no less—from accessing my credit report.

Impossible to File Dispute With Experian


When I requested that Mark fix the problem, the answer was that Experian wouldn’t let him. It made no difference that I made my membership payment to and received my credit reports from Credit Manager. I would have to contact Experian direct to file a dispute, which he “hoped” would solve everything.

After a brief out-of-town trip, I tried to file an online dispute with Experian, giving them every possible bit of personal ID necessary to identify me. The result was a message labeled, “Error.” “We are unable to allow access to our online dispute services at this time.” I thought, by law, they were required to take credit disputes, which I am researching.

Then, a call was made to Experian with a phone number supplied by Mark. I was denied access to my credit report again in an automated telephone call from the number he provided, with the words, “We are unable to process your order.” Then, amazingly, they instructed me to order a credit report by mail, giving me an address. Why? To receive a letter stating that they are unable to process my order by mail? There was absolutely no way to reach a human being from this telephone number, so I called the “useless” folks again.

“Useless” Staff Refuse Dispute Help


All I wanted was for someone to give me an address to file a dispute. As usual, I was “escalated” to the “right” people, but they all refused to give me the “dispute” address. Finally, the last guy noticed my prior activity with Mark, and once again “escalated” me to the Escalation Manager. After a five minute wait, “Mr. Useless” came back on and told me to call Mark in one hour. I did and left word on his voicemail, then had to call back the next day.

Mark, the Escalation Manager, returned my second call, had nothing new to offer, and basically told me there was no more that he could do, intimating that I was on my own. He refused to call his parent, Experian, about my problem, had absolutely no suggestion other than another phone number he was rummaging around in his desk to find, while cautioning me at the same time that he had no idea if it would work. I declined and hung up.

Why has the entire Experian Credit Manager staff been so deceptive in dealing with me in this matter, and why doesn’t Experian provide them with a direct line when everything else fails, as it has in this case? Mark replied to this question by stating that Experian does not want the telephone calls. In other words, just wear them down, as they have in my case, and maybe they will go away. I won’t.

Conspiracy Theory


But could I be wrong about the incompetency? The treatment by Experian’s Credit Manager staff sure seems like I am being jerked around in a concentrated effort to prevent me from seeing my credit records. And, that is my right so that I can protect my family against identity theft.

I’m beginning to smell a conspiracy, a veiled attempt at a warning from the junk mail industry, based on the fact that The Dunning Letter has repeatedly criticized data brokers like Experian—they maintain a database of over 215 million consumers nationwide, with a significant amount of private information other than your credit records—and I am advocating federal legislation to give consumers control over their names and personal data.

More on this later.

Friday, January 16, 2009


THE TIME HAS COME TO HOLD EXPERIAN ACCOUNTABLE


Most posts in The Dunning Letter result from bringing you current events, with some analysis on how they relate to your privacy. On other occasions, such as today, there is a necessity involved that dictates speaking out. The opportunity that presents itself is one of far-reaching concern over the credit bureau Experian, and its level—or lack of—customer service.

On August 18, 2006, I did a post, “Experian Denies My Right to Dispute Credit Report Problem,” after which I have received a parade of comments (28 to date on just this post), e-mails, and visits to this blog with searches titled “Experian dispute.” Earlier in August of 2006, I had done another post, “Level of Competence at Experian Credit Bureau Found to Be Low,” that documented my personal experience of having my credit report go temporarily missing from the paid service I used, Credit Manager, which normally provided 24/7 access online.

In other words, I had uncovered a rash of complaints against Experian, that did not appear to be anywhere near as prevalent with the other two credit bureaus, Equifax and TransUnion.

Speaking of TransUnion, they had their bout with the government and lost, all the way to the Supreme Court. Back in 1992, the Federal Trade Commission filed suit against TransUnion for selling information that was taken from their consumer credit database. The country’s highest court agreed with the FTC, and the practice was stopped.

But in the last couple of weeks I have received at least five comments, some desperate, accompanied with numerous e-mails, from exasperated victims of Experian’s abominable customer service. I can’t imagine what is taking the FTC so long to take action against this credit bureau; The Dunning Letter, alone, has recommended on numerous occasions that Experian casualties file complaints with the FTC.

I even posed this question with a top privacy advocate who also has no idea how long it will take the agency to wake up. This source does emphasize: always file a complaint because eventually the number will be too large to ignore.

This all brings me to an article I read recently in a junk mail industry publication headlined: “Experian Lays Off 130.” Agreed, this was not the company’s credit bureau operation, but rather the marketing arm for selling their database with well over 200 million consumer names and private information. Things like age, income, whether you drink or gamble, what your ailments are and the medications you take for them. The list goes on numbering hundreds of personal things this company knows about you and sells on a daily basis.

The irony of this is, why couldn’t Experian retrain these people and use them in the credit bureau’s “customer service” department, instead of putting them out of work? Anything would be better than the attention the public is getting now.

Experian’s last reported six month period revenues in 2008 generated $1.04 billion in revenue and $251 million is profit. Total company employees number 15,500, less 130. You’d think out of 15,370 people Experian could find someone to handle you complaint.

Maybe it’s time this action made its way to the Supreme Court.

Wednesday, March 19, 2008


PROBLEMS WITH EXPERIAN CREDIT BUREAU HIGHEST SEARCH TOPIC ON THE DUNNING LETTER


Of all the information available on The Dunning Letter that readers could search for, problems with the Experian Credit Bureau—particularly not being able to file a dispute or not being able to even contact the company—top the list. And this doesn’t even include general searches like “credit bureau dispute.” This has been going on since I posted on the fact that my Experian credit report—a report I paid $90 yearly to access—vanished from the system and didn’t return for two months. No explanation, zilch. Links to four posts: one, two, three, four. This all happened mysteriously after I had done some posts on Experian in my blog with unfavorable comments. Not that this was the reason, but, as they say, very coincidental. In addition, there were heated comments to the post links, above, from readers that seemed to be at the end of their rope and ready to pounce on the next person that got in their way. All because of a lack of response from Experian to real problems experienced by these consumers. Based on these experiences, and because ConsumerAffairs.com does such a good job of documenting complaints against the three credit bureaus, I have decided to post regularly on the latest updates, bringing you the current status on problems with these agencies. In future articles I will also report on how consumers are dealing with this dilemma, and link to authoritative sites that provide advice on how to deal with any situation where credit bureaus balk at responding and/or legally following up on complaints. In this first post, Experian will be featured, but the other two credit bureaus, Equifax and TransUnion, will be covered at a later date. Now to the horror stories. There have been 12 of these since the beginning of 2008, all documented on ConsumerAffairs.com Experian Complaints. New Jersey man reports Experian’s refusal to provide free credit reports, after insurance company breached personal data. Bank account frozen due to opening of bogus accounts. New York disabled person puts daughter on credit card account. E transferred his HSBC debt (financial institution with most FTC complaints) to her name and refuses to correct. E would not communicate. Man contacted state Attorney General and got results. Texas disputed inaccurate item, and when E refused to remove, he threatened to sue. He was blocked from credit report, suffered rude treatment. A Chapter 7 bankruptcy wrongfully ends up on Florida’s credit causing score to drop 100 points. E will not respond, cannot get a human on phone. Lost a mortgage on his first home. California received a letter from E stating “someone” had requested change in couple’s names/address and Social Security numbers, but would offer no additional info. After providing copies of passports, driver’s licenses, mortgage statement, and pay stubs, E wanted more identification. Filed complaint with ConsumerAffairs.com. Michigan sent letter with documentation to dispute negative items to E’s president, Kerry Williams, who refused to investigate. Tennessee is in a two year battle with E over credit report problems. Equifax and TransUnion made necessary changes requested, but E continues to be a “nightmare.” To contact Experian, here is the address and telephone number: Experian, P.O. Box 2002, Allen, TX 75013, 1 888 397 3742. If you have the same problems as others have reported, above, I suggest you file complaints with your state attorney general, the FTC, and ConsumerAffairs.com. Good luck!

Monday, February 25, 2008


EXPERIAN CREDIT BUREAU SUES LIFELOCK FOR FALSE ADVERTISING – NOW THAT’S THE EPITOME OF THE POT CALLING THE KETTLE BLACK


Back in August of 2005, the Federal Trade Commission settled a case with Experian Consumer Direct, a subsidiary of the credit bureau, for deception in advertising “free credit reports” by failing to add the customer would be automatically signed up for credit monitoring services costing $79.95 each year. The FTC ordered Experian to give up $950,000 of its “ill-gotten gains. I posted on a personal incident with Experian about a year after this action in which my credit report vanished from the system for a period of two months after I posted some unfavorable comments about the company in my blog, with no explanation from Experian when it mysteriously reappeared. Article one and two. Coincidence or not, I had no record of my credit during that period. Following my first post on this incident, which explained my experience with an Experian customer service department that was completely incompetent, there were 47 comments supporting my findings. Since then, one of the top search engine search topics to my blog has been the problems readers have had with Experian. So now they are at the receiving end and don’t seem to like it. Experian is suing LifeLock, according to one of my favorite blogs, Pogo Was Right, alleging it is losing “millions of dollars a year because of LifeLock’s ‘illegal and fraudulent activities.’” Here’s a copy of the complaint, compliments of Pogo. Experian also claims it suffers a huge expense operating toll-free lines to process fraud alerts for thousands of LifeLock customers. My experience with their toll-free telephone numbers is that, either you can never reach a human being, or, if you do, they are clueless about how to help you. And then there’s the false advertising claim against LifeLock that makes the lawsuit seem like an overblown act of hypocrisy. Don’t get me wrong. I do not believe in paying for identity theft protection that any individual can do free. Aside from the fact that the protection is limited, some companies in this business never deliver what you pay for. There was an offer recently from my U.S. Airways Dividend Miles club for LifeLock, where I can get from 250 to 1000 miles to sign up. Although this may not be a direct endorsement by the airline, it looks like it is, and will be taken by many of its members as a recommendation for the service. In another article on MSNBC, it is reported that LifeLock has 700,000 customers that pay $120 per year for their service. This translates into $84,000,000 in the pockets of the company, most of which results from scare tactics in the media and in advertising, and an unending quest by consumers for “convenience.” On that one word was the junk mail industry built. In the MSNBC piece, Experian contends that LifeLock is no protection against theft already in progress, and in many cases is unable to stop undocumented workers from ripping off you Social Security number to get a job. Are you ready yet to support my grass roots effort to grant consumers control over their names and personal data?

Friday, September 21, 2007


CREDIT BUREAU SCHLOCK: BACK BY POPULAR DEMAND


I did two posts on the Experian credit bureau in August of 2006, when my credit report mysteriously vanished from the system, not to be located by even top Experian and Credit Manager officials. Credit Manager, a branch of Experian, is a paid service I have maintained for over 25 years to monitor my credit activity. See post one and two. My credit report returned to the system, again mysteriously, about two months later without a peep from anyone at Experian or Credit Manager. As if it had never really happened. The reason I use the term mysterious is that the timing was somewhat coincidental with some earlier posts I did on credit bureaus, mentioning Experian. Within minutes after the second post where I talked about Experian’s refusal to allow me to dispute the problem, I had several comments posted with complaints about credit bureaus, one specifically about Experian from someone obviously at the end of their patience. The person said that Experian is incompetent, which agreed with my earlier post comment. In the process of filing a dispute, this person also found out you can only go so far, and then they refuse to let you dispute further. In recent months readers’ interests have been overwhelmingly for more information on either credit bureau disputes or Experian specifically. Unfortunately, nothing new has happened to rectify the problem except a feeble attempt by Washington to look into the matter. The Boston Globe did a story on Barney Frank’s plan to hold hearings about consumers’ ability to correct errors on their credit reports. Frank is a Democrat from Massachusetts, and this was back in December of 2006. The Globe did another piece in June to update hearings that were held, but the findings reported are the same thing privacy advocates have been saying for years. Primarily, data is inaccurate, credit bureaus do not respond to consumer complaints, and victims are frustrated about where to turn. Frank blamed things on the FACT Act, a law meant to improve the credit reporting system passed in 2003, but hung in federal regulatory BS as usual. Obviously the public can’t turn to this Congress based on a statement by the Congressman: “Frank said that he hoped the hearing would spur the agencies to finish the rule (FACT Act), but that new legislation may be required to put the FTC in charge of implementation. Yeah. Like the legislation the Congress was going to pass to protect us from data breaches. Pathetic!

Monday, September 11, 2006

Hewlett Packard Chairwoman, Patricia Dunn, Confirms What Corporate America Thinks About Your Personal Data

Spying on Your Board of Directors?


She said she didn’t realize investigators would use compromising techniques to obtain private phone records of Hewlett Packard’s board members. Where the hell did she think they came from, the cabbage patch? Apparently Patricia Dunn, Chairwoman of HP, does not read or watch news that regularly covers the shady way these data brokers get their information. It’s called “pretexting” and they pose as either the target individual, or an official source, using the person’s personal data: Social Security number, date of birth, etc.

CA AG calls It a Crime


California Attorney General Bill Lockyer has decided a crime has been committed, but he isn’t sure just who to charge yet, according to David Kaplan’s article, “Suspicions and Spies in Silicon Valley,” in Newsweek and on MSNBC. The privacy invasion included the Hewlett Packard board members, as well as journalists from CNET, The Wall Street Journal, Business Week magazine, and The New York Times, according to another MSNBC piece, “U.S. Attorney’s Office looks into HP scandal.”

Aware or Not, a Crime Against all Consumers


Whether or not Patricia Dunn knew what she was doing—anyway, where were her advisors?—it is another blatant act by corporate America that indicates just how little it values your private information. In a recent post, “It’s Monday Morning. Do You Know Where Your Name Is?” I talk about this general disregard for consumers’ sensitive data, and the reason we need federal legislation giving you control over your name and personal data.

Join the grass-roots movement and let me hear from you.


Next: Follow-up on Experian and my LOST Credit Report


It was July 12 when I attempted to access my credit report from Credit Manager, a service for which I pay $90 annually. It is an excellent means to check for identity theft, or any mistakes you might suspect are in your report. My credit report was blank. No information. After 14 e-mails and more telephone calls I care to mention, a supervisor at Credit Manager said, although he, himself, could not even get to my report, there was no more he could do, and I must talk with Experian, one of the big-three credit bureaus, of which Credit Manager is a subsidiary.

See prior stories: “Level of competence at Experian Credit Bureau Found to Be Low,” and “Experian Denies My Right to Dispute Credit Report Problem.”


Incompetence on Top of Incompetence


After suffering through the most incompetent group of customer “service” people I have ever experienced, I was ready to try anything. To make a long story short, Experian refused to even sell me a credit report, and then refused to allow me to dispute what was going on. That did it, and I contacted someone I knew at one of the largest privacy organizations in the country. I was given a name at Experian to e-mail and call. It still took two e-mails and one phone call to talk to this person. That was on September 5. I wasn’t able to access my credit report until Monday, Sept. 11—two months denied access—and the person at Experian has yet to contact me to let me know the problem was fixed.

Experian also maintains several databases with additional sensitive information on just about every household in the country…as well as credit data. Doesn’t this just cry out for that federal legislation to give you control?

Monday, March 16, 2009


DUMBING DOWN ON PRIVACY


FTC goes commercial to combat misleading Experian free credit report ads. If you haven’t fallen for the FreeCreditReport.com come-on advertised by credit bureau Experian, you’re lucky. As we all know, almost nothing is free anymore, especially in this down economy, and Experian’s ploy is no different. The Philadelphia Inquirer reports on a series of commercials being run by the Federal Trade Commission that announces through Irish step dancers and jamming musicians that this “free” offer has strings attached. You do get a free credit report, but to do so you must sign up for Experian’s credit-monitoring service at $14.95 monthly. Some privacy advocates feel this isn’t made completely clear by the credit bureau. I used to subscribe to Experian’s Credit Manager, and when I did unfavorable posts on Experian, my credit report suspiciously vanished for two months. Coincidence? Actually, the FTC commercials are a parody on the Experian ads which had a budget of $300 million, more than the FTC’s entire budget. If you want the real thing, go to AnnualCreditReport.com. Obama’s stimulus program attracts fraudsters. What else? A down economy, millions out of work, and the scam artists are served up their entrĂ©e in the form of the President’s new stimulus package. The bad guys are coming out of the woodwork promising access to thousands of dollars in government funds, often in the form of grants. PC World says that the U.S. Congress, unintentionally of course, created a cottage industry of Web sites and e-mail spammers to carry out the fraud. Web site PresidentObamaGrants.com sucked in the suckers with a sign-up fee of $2, adding an additional $99 to their credit card if they didn’t cancel within 14 days. Not satisfied, the crooks charged a monthly fee of $49.95, plus $29.95 for a debt-related service, all of which could add up to over $1,000 for a year. Another site, OfficialStimulusGrants.com followed suit, but charging $94.89 each month if the consumer didn’t cancel in a 7 day period. Stealing your money is, of course, the issue, but some are also asking for personal information, which could lead to long-term ID theft. Junk mailers don’t consider consumer privacy a “basic” of marketing. In the March 2009 issue of Direct, a junk mail industry publication, there is an article titled, “Just the Basics.” Taken from a marketing research report prepared by Anderson Analytics, it covers marketers’ concerns for their customers during a recession. Blatantly and astonishingly missing is the security of consumer names and personal data. Don’t know why that surprises me, since during my 35 years as a junk mail list/data broker, it was rare that I could engage clients or large database companies in a conversation about improved protection of customer sensitive data. Here’s the way the report stacks up. First is “customer satisfaction,” followed by “customer retention,” then “ROI,” “brand loyalty,” and a host of other technology concerns that are boring to the average reader. I would give you a link to the site but you have to sign up to access it, a move that might have been prompted by recent criticisms of junk mailers from blogs like The Dunning Letter. There is one highlight, the fact that junk mailers increasingly feel basing marketing functions overseas may not be so good, but still for selfish reasons. They were afraid of the risk, and it wasn’t as profitable. At least they are consistent.

Friday, March 27, 2009


THINK YOUR FTC COMPLAINT DOESN’T MATTER? READ ON


Before actually getting into the protocol for complaining, there are a couple of laws with which you should be familiar. First, the Fair Debt Collect Practices Act (FDCPA) which “prohibits debt collectors and collection attorneys from using undue harassment and other unethical practices when collecting debt.” This, according to BCSalliance.com, a website for consumers on handling debt. Second, the FTC Act, from Wikipedia, launched the Federal Trade Commission which was given the power to prevent unfair methods of competition, and/or deceptive acts or practices against consumers.

That said, I ran across a blog recently, CarreonandAssociates,com, which proves the potential clout of the FTC, even in a Bush administration. The article, “Biggest FTC crackdown on collection agency ever. 2.25 million,” published in December 2008, documents how Academy Collection Services abused their rights as a debt collector. More than 1,000 complaints were filed against the company with the FTC and states’ attorneys general. Lydia Parnes, Director of the FTC’s Bureau of Consumer Protection says, “They ignored people’s complaints and rewarded the collectors who broke the law. This is not a business model that the FTC tolerates.”

If you are wondering where I am going here, it’s all about those of you who have complained about companies like Experian Credit Bureau in the past, but felt that actually filing a complaint with the FTC was useless. And for all those “Apathetics” out there who complain to themselves, friends or relatives, but never take action on their problem. Please read the above article. If a $2.25 million fine—the largst civil fine ever obtained by the FTC—doesn’t convince Academy Collection Service to do the right thing, probably nothing will. But the system worked.

And speaking of Experian, they were fined twice by the FTC for deceptive advertising in the sale of credit reports. Once in August of 2005 for $950,000, and again in February of 2007 for $300,000. Folks, both of these fines are for the same thing, proving this company will push the envelope if it has to in the sale of your names and personal data. I did a post on Experian in August of 2006 about how they denied my right to dispute a problem. This resulted from my complete credit report mysteriously vanishing from their system for a period of two months right after I had written critical posts about Experian.

In the above Experian post, there are a total of 42 comments as of today, most of which reference problems with the credit bureau. In each case I provided the FTC online complaint site, and if readers followed through, that is a good start in mounting the drive to bring charges against Experian…again. This is only one blog, and when you search “Experian consumer complaints” on Google blog search, you get almost 4,000 hits. Hopefully many of these blogs are recommending readers complain to the FTC.

As a result of the 1,000 complaints against Academy Collection Services, the Justice Dept. filed a complaint against the company on behalf of the FTC, resulting eventually in the $2.25 million fine against Academy. So just keep this in mind when you are wronged by business, and think you have nowhere to turn. And, hopefully, FTC action against these companies will improve under the Obama administration.

Monday, July 23, 2007


JUST HOW INCOMPETENT WILL U.S. GOVERNMENT AGENCIES BECOME?


If I had to really guess, my conclusion would be that there’s still more ineptitude coming. Especially when it comes to protecting the privacy rights of consumers. The House of Representatives is probing just why the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the Federal Reserve haven’t implemented law to help the American public repair errors in their credit reports, according to an article by ConsumerAffairs.com. In a 2004 study done by the U.S. Public Research Interest Group, 79 percent of the credit reports checked had errors of some kind; 25 percent had errors that could result in denial of credit. The law House members refer to requires the major credit bureaus (Experian, Equifax, and TransUnion) to “overhaul their customer support procedures and provide free credit reports.” Apparently this isn’t getting done, and Rep. Carolyn Maloney (D-NY) is accusing the Feds of consistent inaction. I wonder how many of these House members are also talking to junk mail and financial industry lobbyists regularly about just why they don’t want the law implemented? Odds are there are several, and the reason they want the inaction to continue is money. Free reports and good customer service costs them mucho bucks, and spending money on the consumer is not in their short term or long term plans. Case in point. For years I have subscribed to Experian’s Credit Manager for $90 a year to be able to access my credit report and credit score any time I want to. Nothing had ever gone wrong until I posted articles on Experian that were unfavorable but true. Soon after, my entire credit history vanished from Credit Manager, and I was unable to access the report. You can read two stories on this issue: “Level of Competence at Experian Credit Bureau Found to Be Low,” and “Experian Denies My Right to Dispute Credit Report Problem.” In summary, I ran into the most incompetent group of customer service representatives—and that includes every level of management—that I have ever experienced anywhere. My credit report finally returned mysteriously, but I have never been given a reason why this happened. Privacy advocates at the House hearing argued that the credit reporting industry has been cost-cutting in their compliance of the FACTA law, which is the one in question, and are even outsourcing their dispute processing to low-wage countries like the Philippines, Jamaica, and Costa Rica. National Consumer Law Center staff attorney, Chi Chi Wu, says credit bureaus “treat disputes as a nuisance…devoting as little resources as possible by using automation that produces formalistic results.” As a major recipient in the $4 billion made annually from the sale of names and personal data, it is time for credit bureaus to clean up their act!

Friday, March 09, 2007


EXPERIAN PAYS HEAVILY FOR FAILURE TO DISCLOSE


Broken promises abound in the credit granting industry. One such situation finds Experian’s Consumerinfo.com recently paying $300,000 to settle with the Federal Trade Commission on charges that ads for its “free credit report” offer failed to tell folks they would automatically be enrolled in an ongoing monitoring program for $79.95 a year. The company had already paid a $950,000 fine in August of 2005 charging that it was deceptively marketing “free credit reports.” In the beginning, Consumerinfo.com told consumers they must provide a credit card which was “required only to establish your account.” They then automatically renewed some consumers by charging their credit cards without notice, according to the FTC. I subscribe to Experian’s Credit Manager in order to check my credit report for unauthorized use. A couple months ago Experian shut down my credit report, denying me access for a period of days. It was right after I did an unfavorable blog post on the company. After enlisting the help of a major privacy advocate, the report was up and available again. Experian had absolutely no answer for the problem. Go figure.

Thursday, February 14, 2008


CHUTZPAH OR ARROGANCE. YOU DECIDE


In a December 2007 article from Multichannel Merchant by Denise Hopkins, she documents how data collectors can turn your innocent credit card purchase into a treasure trove of valuable information in the form of appending additional personal data. Hopkins is the vice president of marketing and product development for Experian Marketing Services, one of the top five consumer database companies, and top three credit bureaus in the country. The reason that it is important to spend this extra money to better identify you is that one-third of all consumer purchases are with credit cards, amounting to $40 out of each $100 spent. The Experian VP states that the customer is already aware of the company’s “brand,” with the implication that this makes building a profile of the individual OK. It is not! What it is is a sneak attack through the back door building a dossier on this person who has no inclination of what is going on. Although there is no mention of selling this information—in junk mail circles when you buy something from one of these companies, that usually translates into the right for them to sell your name and personal data—and that is the business of the Experian Marketing Services division. As a former list broker, I bought lists from them for years. You can, of course, opt out of the sale of your sensitive data but in Hopkins’ process, this is an afterthought. She even gives a blueprint of how to pull off the caper. You lift the information from the magnetic strip on the back of the card, which normally includes the card holder’s name and address. Then, proceed to the third party data service—which Experian provides—to append the extra juicy stuff like your age, income, occupation, education, home value, and the list goes on and on. They even know if you gamble, drink, smoke and have your medical ailments and prescriptions taken. Denise Hopkins may not have had any of the scenarios I have created here in mind. What I can assure you is that it is all possible—and with the junk mail industry committed to collecting and selling every morsel of private consumer information they can get their hands on—it is also likely. So you tell me. Is it chutzpas or arrogance? Or have junk mailers really convinced themselves that they own our names and personal data, and may do with them exactly as they please? I believe it is the latter. See more posts on Experian here, here and here.

Wednesday, August 09, 2006

Level of Competence at Experian Credit Bureau Found to Be Low

Identity Theft Concern


I am a member of Credit Expert, Experian’s Credit Manager service that normally provides me instant online access to my credit report. I pay $90 annually for this membership, and have been a loyal customer for over twenty-five years. Until today. During a periodic checkup to insure against identity theft, I was unable to get to my data. That was July 12, four weeks ago.

After 14 e-mails, all of which resulted in no resolution from a staff so inadequate it is incomprehensible they hold their jobs, I finally received a telephone number to call. Apparently, I had gone through this boiler room full of dummies—God only knows where they were—and at least one had the inclination to hand me off to someone else. That was last Friday, July 28.

After another complete explanation to someone equally as inept by the name of Bemi, I was put on hold several times for durations up to three minutes. I’m guessing that wasn’t enough since he finally got back to me with the answer that my problem had been “escalated” to the proper party, and I would hear from them within 48 hours.

The “problem” is that I cannot check my credit report to make sure there is nothing going on that is fraudulent. It involves logging on to Credit Expert, then proceeding to look at “inquiries;” anyone that has accessed my credit report. At the same time you can scan all your credit history, and confirm that the data is correct. That is, if you can get to it. I couldn’t.

248 Names, Personal Data Breaches Since 2005


Since ChoicePoint started the parade in February of 2005, Privacy Rights Clearinghouse reports almost 250 breaches of sensitive data in everything from Social Security numbers to medical records. Just fewer than 90 million records of your private information was on the open market, at least temporarily, even if it was eventually recovered. And for what hasn’t been recovered, don’t feel any comfort in the fact that you, personally, haven’t experienced fraud. The new identity criminal is smart, and willing to wait until the heat is off to tear into your credit.

I didn’t see Experian on the list of breaches—TransUnion, another credit bureau, was—but if the frontal guard I dealt with is any indication of the rest of the company’s proficiency, they are due any day. I worked with this organization—as well as Equifax and TransUnion—during my 35 years selling names and personal data in the junk mail industry. It is this experience, among others, that led me into privacy activism, and the launch of this blog.

Nowhere to Turn for Credit Dispute


Returning to the Experian episode, there was no call or e-mail in over 72 hours, so another contact was made. This time, I started with a quick explanation of the situation, with a demand to speak to a supervisor. Anthony sounded somewhat competent, but with absolutely no authority to help me in any way; it took over an hour to learn this. He could only listen and “escalate” the problem elsewhere.

Anthony gave me a telephone number to request an immediate credit report, and file a dispute over my credit report that was inaccessible. Result, it was “automated response” only, and I must purchase a credit report for $10 before I can file the dispute, with no human being within miles. Upon recalling Anthony, he confirmed all this, at which time I almost went postal.

The outcome was that he was again “escalating” my problem to the right people, and he would have them call me within two hours. They didn’t, but I did hear from someone at Credit Expert later in the day. He was late responding because Anthony hadn’t given him proper contact information.

But, you’d never guess who called. The Escalation Manager. More on this later.

Thursday, June 02, 2005

Junk Mail 101: The Tragic Omnipresence of Your Name and Personal Data

If you think all you have to worry about is ChoicePoint and LexisNexis, when it comes to large, data brokers warehousing your name and personal data…well, think again. I’m about to spill the beans on the “big five” in junk mail that compile names and private information from multiple sources and cryptically unite this data in the storehouses of their technological jungles.

These collectors of information are the scavengers of junk mail. Their cornucopias of endless data transform your daily life into an open book. They are creatures of habit, seizing every opportunity to corral every morsel of your existence. They are: Abacus Catalog Alliance, Acxiom, Equifax, Experian and TransUnion. The latter three are also credit bureaus who supply your financial information to businesses and individuals.

What do the “big five” know about you? What personal data of yours do they sell to the junk mail community? How secure is your private information within these knowledge-based giants? I’m glad you asked, but, first, a recent news item that will set the stage for this journey.

It’s about a guy named Jeremy MacKinney who received a letter recently from LexisNexis advising him that some of his personal data might be on the loose. You can read the story on MSNBC.com, but Jeremy’s initial low level of worry escalated quickly when he found out what the lost information was.

Yep, there it was, the Social Security number, his current employer, each of his moves for the past twelve years, including a stint in a California monastery. There were past roommates and family, along with their demographics, and, yep, even their Social Security numbers.

The article, “Hacker’s assaults may prod reforms,” is worth your time and makes several good points, among them the fact that these companies have tons of information on consumers and they sell it everywhere without your permission. So, exactly who are they?

The Abacus Catalog Alliance is a breeding colossus, with over 90-million households stocked with your intimate purchasing facts, including when and how many times you purchase, how much you paid, what you bought and your credit card numbers. Over 1,500 of the top catalogs you shop from funnel this information into Abacus, where they maintain precise data on some 4.4 billion buying transactions from your purchases.

Acxiom’s InfoBase can best be described as a “monster.” Over 200 items of your most private data—total value vehicles owned, available home equity and market value, date of birth, gambling and drinking habits, your politics, etc.—from 176 million individuals in 114 million households. That’s pretty much all of us, isn’t it? Acxiom, like ChoicePoint, has Homeland Security contracts, garnered with the help of retired General and former presidential candidate, Wesley Clark, who is an Acxiom-paid board member; $300,000 in 2002.

Equifax, another behemoth rears its head. In addition to their treasure-trove of credit data, the company has two lists that, again, seem to assemble all of us into a huge, neat package. Over 107 million households with 31 different sources of data, divided into more than 150 personalized characteristics. Add to that 47 million households with 500 personal lifestyle habits including credit cards used, products purchased through specific channels, ie., books or for children, if you are dieting or a gambler, frequent travelers, your online service, long distance carrier, average LD bill and if you make international calls.

And then there’s Experian, another credit provider with two lists very similar to Equifax. Because these similarities are so pronounced, there is another story I’d like to tell you about Experian’s predecessor, Metromail Corp. Before the latter was acquired by Experian, it decided to save money by using prisoners to capture personal information from surveys. Now you have an individual in the slammer for who knows what and that person is in control of your most intimate data.

Well, the obvious happened. The info was used to intimidate a woman by sending her mail from a convicted rapist and burglar. The woman filed legal action against Metromail, a class-action suit resulted, and the company is no longer allowed to use prisoners to process their surveys. The irony here is that Metromail thought they had breached no privacy.

Finally, there’s TransUnion, the third credit provider that is also instrumental in all those junk mail offers you receive for auto insurance. In a scoring system based on your credit worthiness, they provide casualty insurers names of those they deem qualified. They also sell lists of millions of names from selective titles such as “Outer Limits.” That’s households with a premium credit card, department store card, upscale card, a bank card, either a finance loan or jewelry buyers or home furnishings buyers. I tell you this because it takes some extreme analysis of your personal data to justify putting a list of this nature on the market.

However, TransUnion’s claim to fame is when they were turned down by the U.S. Supreme Court for their efforts to sell your name along with your highly sensitive data. They had been a persistent litigator for years to sell your private information their way, including a ten-year battle with the Federal Trade Commission, which they also lost.

Some of the above data is compiled from public records, some from surveys you willingly complete to receive free products. The balance is from a multitude of private sources, a subject that is in itself worth a separate post in the future.

If you’re interested, click on the above sites and marvel over how your name is being sold. If you’re a mind to, use the “contact” button on each site, except for TransUnion, to tell these companies what you think about what they are doing with your name and personal data. Contact TU at: TransUnion, P.O. Box 2000, Chester, PA 19022.

Saturday, September 29, 2007


DUMBING DOWN ON PRIVACY


Junk mailers need more honesty in their editorializing. That’s my answer to an editorial in the junk mail industry publication, DM News, with the headline “Consumers need more data knowledge” by Eleanor Trickett, Ed. In Chief. In the first sentence she cites “government laptops stolen,” but fails to mention the breach by junk mail data broker ChoicePoint, which put this whole identity theft issue in motion. She proceeds to talk about how much information consumers are asked to give up for the sake of convenience or a discount, but completely skirts the fact that junk mailers are the ones to blame for this insane drive to find out everything there is to know about every individual in the US. Just once I would like to see these people come right out and say, “This identity crisis is all our fault, and it’s time we did something to stop it.” Yeah. That’ll be the day. Junk mailers are lobbying their way out of federal legislation they don’t want and the consumer is the loser. It’s so obvious by the fact there isn’t one piece of data breach legislation that is close to becoming a law. CNNMoney.com did a recent piece on ChoicePoint’s lobbying expenditures: $500,000 in just the first half of 2007. I figured if CP was doing this, other junk mail data brokers couldn’t be far behind. I was so right. OpenSecrets.org is a great site to find things that business and government would rather you didn’t know. I went to their Lobbying Database and this is what I found on the top data brokers and credit bureaus: Acxiom spent $160,000; Lexis Nexis $40,000, their parent, Reed Elsevier, $3,380,000; Experian $300,000; Equifax $100,000; and TransUnion $80,000. Experian, Equifax and TransUnion are credit bureaus, as well as maintaining huge consumer databases chock full of personal data as well. You have to wonder what all this money buys, but a quick guess would be favorable data breach legislation, or none at all. Phishing just got more sophisticated, and they’re taking on the GOV. The latest uses an IRS front to contact someone offering a tax refund, for which you have to give up private information, of course. According to ZDNet.com, the bad guys send thousands of e-mails that in many cases are hard to differentiate from the real thing. So much so, 8.2 percent of online households have taken the bait losing an estimated $630 million. The Government Accountability Office (GAO) puts the figure at $1 billion annually. Most people hate statistics but you’d better pay attention to these, because they have the potential for significant growth, considering the number of federal agencies that deal with the public. This is a trend, folks, and it isn’t going away. It will only get worse unless you join my grass-roots movement to grant consumers control over their names and personal data, with compensation to the name-holder when it is sold. Let me hear from you!

Monday, February 16, 2009


CREDIT CARD SOLICITATIONS GO UNDERGROUND


If your income is less than $100,000 annually, you received 26 percent less credit card offers in 2008, compared to 2007. A prime example of how the junk mail industry manipulates your personal data to maneuver consumers to respond the way they want them to. According to Mintel Comperemedia, who does research for junk mailers, announcing in a ConsumerAffairs report, funds for lending were down, and with the credit card companies already losing on current loans—apparently from those with incomes less than $100,000—they cut mailings back significantly.

Does that halt the barrage on our mailboxes? Not really. They just found another surrogate: businesses you are already dealing with that veil the solicitation under their name, hoping you will make the assumption they endorse the credit card offer. Of course, the business gets a cut from each application returned.

It goes like this. Holland America Line’s headline exclaims: “Presenting the Holland America Line Rewards Visa Card…Your next cruise is closer than you think.” We are cruisers but we have never been on Holland America, so why would I feel any relationship toward them. This is relationship marketing, or affinity, or third party, meaning the company uses their relationship with the customer to sell you something they have absolutely no control over if something goes wrong.

On the other hand, we have been on Princess Cruises, from which we have received two offers in the last couple of weeks. U.S. Airways has hit us twice in the same period of time, and the list goes on. This has been going on in junk mail for at least 35 years, and in bad economic times can be a boon to both of the businesses involved. By sharing the cost of the mailing, or riding piggyback in the company’s regular mail, everyone wins, except the consumer.

I say that because a 2009 survey just released by Javelin Strategy & Research says that 33 percent of the respondents reported that new credit card accounts were opened fraudulently in their name in 2008. That’s an increase of 27 percent over 2007. It only takes the crooks a few minutes on the underground Internet to buy your personal information like Social Security, date of birth, etc., and they are on their way.

You may eventually prove to the credit card provider that you weren’t the bad guys, but you will have a much larger battle convincing the three credit bureaus, Equifax, TransUnion and Experian, to correct your credit history, especially Experian. As an example, the average resolution time to fix your credit in 2008 was 30 hours, up from 26 in 2007.

In the near future I am going to review the complete Javelin 2009 Identity Fraud Survey Report. Here’s a preview of what they found. Identity fraud victims increased 22 percent to 9.9 million in 2008. Economic downturn historically results in increased domestic fraud. Traditional access to private data continues to be commonplace (emphasis added by me). For the consumer version—which I highly recommend reading for some great insights into preventing or dealing with ID theft—go here.

Tuesday, September 26, 2006

FTC Drops the Ball...Again

Can’t Reach a Human? You’re Not Alone


I can deal with talking to an automated telephone system when it comes to getting my latest bank balance, or calling the airlines for flight arrivals. I cannot tolerate this electronic technology when a series of button commands could not possibly answer my question. That was the case in my recent Experian incident, and many of your comments indicated you have had the same problem. The credit reporting company even denied my right to dispute at one point.

Shouldn’t Credit Reporting Agencies Be Required to Talk to Us?


When someone is handling information as delicate as your credit history, and you are in a critical situation requiring immediate attention, contact with a competent human being should be a given. It isn’t at Experian. It took me 14 e-mails to pry a telephone number out of the most incompetent crew of customer service representatives I have ever experienced. And then, when at the top of the pecking order, with my dilemma still unsolved, the guy left me stranded, telling me there was no more he could do for me.

Who You Know Still Works Best


It was only after asking a privacy colleague for help that I got the telephone number that did the job. Bingo. Problem solved in a couple of days, and after two follow-up calls—these people never return the first call—a credit was issued for the two months I was not able to access my credit report from Credit Manager.

Apparently, the fact that thousands of consumers cannot reach a human being at the big three credit reporting agencies, isn’t a priority for the FTC. Not satisfied yet, I am researching the Federal Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), and Gramm-Leach-Bliley to determine if there is any stipulation in either of the bills to cover this issue. More on this later.

FTC’s Strike Number Two


Eight months after the Federal Trade Commission’s settlement with ChoicePoint—the gang that started the tide of data breaches in 2005—a $5 million fund for the 800 victims hasn’t paid out a penny. The FTC shouted success and waved flags exclaiming “look what we did,” but failed to plan just how to do it. Sounds like the other gang that thought they could coast after the Iraq war.

It is all very discouraging, because it shows a bureaucratic unwillingness to do something about the identity crisis from the Bush administration, to Congress, right on down to the government agencies that are supposed to regulate this issue. More fodder for my concept that consumers should control their names and personal data, and be paid any time they are used.

Tuesday, September 19, 2006

Pretexting Is Just the Latest Buzzword, Not the Problem

The Problem Is Who Warehouses Your Names and Personal Data


Yes, “pretexting” is another unwanted complication in the identity crisis, but the real problem is the data brokers that aggregate your names and private information into a neat bundle and sell it to the information brokers that do the pretexting. To name the biggest, ChoicePoint, Acxiom, LexisNexis, Experian, Equifax, and TransUnion. There are hundreds more smaller companies, and the Big Six are not only the biggest, but, in most cases, the ones who collect the personal data and disseminate it to the others.

Abysmal Track Record in Accuracy


In a study by the Privacy Activism group, they found inaccuracies in 67% of Acxiom consumer reports, 73% for ChoicePoint. This included errors in basic data such as name, Social Security number, address and phone number. The Big Three Credit Bureaus, Experian, Equifax and TransUnion, had mixed results. Rated as a group, not individually, the Public Interest Research Group (PIRG) found that 25% of the Big Three credit reports had errors serious enough to deny credit. Overall, the mistake level was 79%. A Federal Reserve Bank study in 2005 of mistakes reported by consumers in their credit reports was in a range of from 20 to 40 percent.

Your Private Information Available Worldwide


When you “Google” information brokers—as distinguished from data brokers—using “quotes,” you get a total of 319,000, with 90 in the U.S., 243 in Europe, and 100 in Australia. That leaves the remaining some 318,500 distributed throughout the rest of the world. If a Nigerian information broker was pretexting in America, he would most likely have to get his data from one of the Big Six data brokers. You may remember that the perpetrator of the data breach at ChoicePoint that opened the identity crisis in February of 2005 was Nigerian-born Olatunji Oluwatosin. And, it isn’t clear if one of the Big Six would release private information to a pretexter of Nigerian origin, because they don’t identify their clients.

Control…Control…Control


The data brokers will continue to collect every piece of your personal data they can, and sell it to any information broker they want until you put a stop to it by demanding federal legislation that will give you control over your name and private information. The elections are coming. Now is the time to contact Congressional representatives: House of Representatives; Senate.

Wednesday, April 26, 2006

Junk Mail Ethics

Back in December of 2005, the Direct Marketing Assn. (DMA) published an article on its website that identifies current action against three companies for lack of cooperation in solving matters of ethics. Neither of the companies is a member of DMA, so therefore, they really don’t have to cooperate. They didn’t, and there’s really not much more the organization can do but refer the companies on to the appropriate law enforcement authority.

What the DMA did do in the article, “DMA Releases Latest Ethics Report; Refers Listing Service to FCC,” is compile a list of six issues of primary concern, based on 20 current cases. Based on my 35 years as a broker of mailing lists, I am impressed with the issues, but not moved in the least with what I know of junk mail compliance. Four are worth mentioning, however.

Number one: Customer information should not be readily available for access by other individuals; here they are primarily concerned with services that make this data available online. “Customers would not reasonably expect that information about what they purchased, or how they responded to a marketing survey, would result in their inclusion in an online look-up service.”

One of the most lucrative areas of selling your name and personal data comes from marketing surveys you complete to get free products. OK. We’re all frugal to a point, but if you knew how quick and widely distributed your private information was after filling out these detailed questionnaires, you’d think twice next time.

The giants of this gold mine are Equifax and Experian, both credit reporting firms. Their subsidiaries, Lifestyle Selector and Behaviorbank, maintain databases of your personal data and daily habits, numbering 56 million and 40 million households, respectively. Things like what you read, what you drink, what ailments you have and the medications you take, how you invest, if you smoke and what brand, whether you gamble…and much, much more.

And these aren’t the only companies who assemble and sell this data. Be assured that just about anytime you put your private information on paper, online, or give it up by telephone, it will be collected and sold to the highest bidder. There are billions of dollars to be made, and you won’t realize one penny in the deal. To add insult to injury, you might even suffer identity theft down the line.

Please tell me, what is worse? Making the survey data available to Web surfers online (as is the point of the article’s issue), or selling it to thousands of junk mailers that, as we have already experienced, can lose the data to potential ID thieves? The DMA’s focus is typical of an industry that covets the sale of your name and personal data, and is willing to protect this supposed right at any risk.

It’s already enough that Equifax and Experian turn over this data for the marketing strategies of those companies who provide you the free products. It’s equally troubling that they fail to make it clear to you that your private information will be sold over, and over, and over…ad infinitum.

If you, the consumer, had control over this personal data, there wouldn’t be a problem, and you would be enjoying the fruits of the sale of this data.

Next issue of concern, the “teaser” copy on junk mail envelopes that bribe you to open them.

Thursday, August 25, 2005

Ethnic Profiling In Junk Mail II

In an October 2001, article titled, “Ethnic Profiling: A Rational and Moral Framework,” by Robert A. Levy, Senior Fellow in Constitutional Studies for the Cato Institute, he reports on a then Gallup poll which revealed that 60% of Americans wanted Arabs to be subjected to more intensive screening at airports. Of course, this was less than a month after 9/11. He quickly raises the question of whether any ethnic or racial profiling should ever be justified.

And then in August of this year, Ralph Hostetter’s piece, “Ethnic Profiling,” on CNSNEWS.COM, takes the ACLU to task for attempting to organize the Far Left, ultra liberals, against such targeted, ethnic profiling. The ACLU objects because terrorist acts such as Oklahoma City, the Atlanta Olympics, even a Taliban insurgent, were all Anglo-Christian Americans. But Hostetter apparently still feels this weakens the U.S. fight against terrorism and puts our citizens in jeopardy.

Levy believes, …”we must defeat without abandoning the liberties that set us apart from every other country in the world.” He goes on to call for “logic, not emotion,” “evidence, not rumor,” and …”a structured approach that weighs the competing interests rationally and morally.”

On the other hand, Hostetter states, “It is politically stupid for Americans who are so easily identified on an ethnic basis not to use ethnic profiling against our sworn enemies in the interests of our own protection.” He goes on, “Ethnic profiling works. If ethnic profiling is but one viable tool in the war against international terrorism, it must be used to the utmost.”

Two somewhat opposing views, but each with a certain degree of substance. We must defend America but we must not take away or infringe upon the civil rights of the people. And, under no circumstances should we be allowed to invade the privacy of any home or individual without confirmed provocation.

Keeping both of these positions in mind, let’s continue where we left off in my last post with the parade of ethnic lists that prevail in the junk mail industry.

Ethnic Lists & Marketing, LLC of Scottsdale, AZ, has a list called “Arab-American/Muslim-American Doctors.” There are 6,431 nationwide. Here’s one from Ethnic Technologies, LLC of South Hackensack, NJ, “Arabic Prime Prospects.” They also have “Turkish Speaking Households.” Three more from ClientLogic: “Ethnic Clubs & Organizations,” Islamic Households by Occupation,” and “Islamic Lifestyle Index” which identifies Islamic homes with guns and ammunition.

There’s an ethnic database of e-mail addresses from List Services Direct in Leonia, NY, and a huge ethnic masterfile of millions of names with added personal data from Focus USA, Hackensack, NJ. All of the smaller lists have some personal data available. Items include age of adults and children, telephone number, income, occupation, credit card usage, length of residence, language spoken, investments, education, vehicle information, frequent travelers, and, my favorite, “people interested in Middle East politics and the Arab-Israeli conflict.”

Some of the major magazines are also very aggressive in this area. Entrepreneur, U.S. News & World Report, Newsweek, the Time Inc. Group, Hearst Magazines (Cosmopolitan, Esquire, Good Housekeeping, Harper’s Bazaar, Popular Mechanics and Redbook, to name a few), and Meredith Magazines including Better Homes & Gardens and Ladies Home Journal. All have ethnic selections on lists that range in size from 500 thousand to over 30 million, the latter being the Time Inc. Group.

But the “mother” of all ethnic lists comes from Experian, also one of the three credit report providers, covering 43 different ethnic origins, and including 84 million individuals. That’s 28% of the total population. In addition to age, income, occupation, education, etc., here’s what Experian also knows about these households: whether they are business owners; number of children and their gender; wealth rating; and their summarized credit statistics.

As I indicated in my last post on “Ethnic Profiling In Junk Mail,” the real purpose of amassing all this data into lists and databases is to make more money from the sale of the names and personal information. Which is OK, if the name-holders were getting their fair share. Ethnic names range in price from 7 cents to 16 cents, the high side being just over the average of 15 cents.

As a part of the $4 billion made annually from the sale of consumers’ names and personal data, ethnic lists probably don’t represent a major contribution…yet. But considering the federal government’s recent habits of using data brokers as major investigative tools, can that time for typical overspending in this field by the feds, accompanied by humongous privacy abuses, be far away?

Read all about this in Rebecca Carr’s article, “Government employing brokers as data posse,” taken from the Palm Beach Post-Cox News Service. She reports that federal agencies still use companies like ChoicePoint and Seisint Inc. (LexisNexis) despite activist and lawmaker concerns over their recent data breaches and about this potential invasion of our privacy. You can only assume from this that we do not ever learn from our mistakes.

Friday, May 30, 2008


ACXIOM PROVIDES BUSINESS NEW AUTHENTICATION OF ONLINE CUSTOMERS. BUT, HOW ACCURATE IS IT?


Junk mail data broker, Acxiom, has just announced that it will introduce a new service, FactCheck-X Authenticate, to business clients based on unique biographically based questions asked of online customers that are designed to qualify them with the company they are contacting. This could be logging into your stock portfolio, accessing your bank statements, or perhaps even looking at your medical records. In an article on PR-inside.com, “businesses are more secure and customers can experience a better online authentication experience.” I doubt the latter, and here’s the reason why.

In 2005—and if anyone finds a later report please let me know—the non-profit Privacy Activism did a study to determine the accuracy of biographical information in two major data brokers, Acxiom and ChoicePoint. Acxiom’s authentication, above, is based on biographical data. It was discovered that even in the most basic information like name, address, phone number, Social Security number, errors were found in 67 percent of Acxiom’s reports. If this has been corrected, I welcome factual substantiation that it has.

NewsEnet.com provides insight into some of those biographical questions inquiring consumer minds might be faced with.

• In what subdivision do you live?

• Where does your brother Mike live?

• Select a state which you were previously licensed to drive.

• How many fireplaces are in your current residence?

OK, what if both Mike and I just moved? Will Acxiom allow for this mistake, and then ask where the former residences were? The fact that they are asking anything about my driver’s license bothers me, but I guess telling them about my fireplace won’t hurt.

Jennifer Barrett, Acxiom’s chief privacy officer, won’t reveal specific sources of your biographical data, but adds that it did come from “public document files and private sources.” She also cites the Patriot Act as a crutch for doing this, which immediately throws up warning flags and reminders of NSA’s warrantless spying. Lee Tien of non-profit Electronic Frontier Foundation sees no advantage to the service. Others can find out many of these facts about you, and her opinion is that a random, newly assigned PIN would be safer.

I did a post in February of this year where it is shown how your name and personal information are eternalized—similar to your name and date of passing on your tombstone—in data broker databanks across this country and throughout the world. The major companies responsible for collecting your private information and archiving it forever are Experian, TransUnion, Equafax, ChoicePoint, and of course Acxiom. The first three are also credit bureaus, holding your most precious credit data as well.

In March of 2007, another post was done on Acxiom’s new connection to May Company stores, which were eventually converted to Macy’s. Acxiom was enhancing the Macy’s list—including Bloomingdale’s, also a part of Federated Stores—with customer personal data, among which is your age, income, plus a number of other demographic characteristics, then purchase and lifestyle behavior like health interests, religion, credit cards held, politics, cell phone owners, investments, reading and vacation habits, and wine drinkers. If you are a Macy’s or Bloomingdale’s card holder—there are over 3.6 million—go to this site to see what all they know about you.

So the next time you shop at Macy’s or Bloomingdale’s online, they might ask you if you have arthritis, or if you like baseball, if you are on a diet, what shape your houseplants are in, or how was your recent skiing trip? If you can’t answer the questions, don’t be surprised if they hesitate to sell you a collar for your cat, which they already know you own.