Search This Blog

Showing posts sorted by date for query experian. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query experian. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Friday, March 27, 2009


THINK YOUR FTC COMPLAINT DOESN’T MATTER? READ ON


Before actually getting into the protocol for complaining, there are a couple of laws with which you should be familiar. First, the Fair Debt Collect Practices Act (FDCPA) which “prohibits debt collectors and collection attorneys from using undue harassment and other unethical practices when collecting debt.” This, according to BCSalliance.com, a website for consumers on handling debt. Second, the FTC Act, from Wikipedia, launched the Federal Trade Commission which was given the power to prevent unfair methods of competition, and/or deceptive acts or practices against consumers.

That said, I ran across a blog recently, CarreonandAssociates,com, which proves the potential clout of the FTC, even in a Bush administration. The article, “Biggest FTC crackdown on collection agency ever. 2.25 million,” published in December 2008, documents how Academy Collection Services abused their rights as a debt collector. More than 1,000 complaints were filed against the company with the FTC and states’ attorneys general. Lydia Parnes, Director of the FTC’s Bureau of Consumer Protection says, “They ignored people’s complaints and rewarded the collectors who broke the law. This is not a business model that the FTC tolerates.”

If you are wondering where I am going here, it’s all about those of you who have complained about companies like Experian Credit Bureau in the past, but felt that actually filing a complaint with the FTC was useless. And for all those “Apathetics” out there who complain to themselves, friends or relatives, but never take action on their problem. Please read the above article. If a $2.25 million fine—the largst civil fine ever obtained by the FTC—doesn’t convince Academy Collection Service to do the right thing, probably nothing will. But the system worked.

And speaking of Experian, they were fined twice by the FTC for deceptive advertising in the sale of credit reports. Once in August of 2005 for $950,000, and again in February of 2007 for $300,000. Folks, both of these fines are for the same thing, proving this company will push the envelope if it has to in the sale of your names and personal data. I did a post on Experian in August of 2006 about how they denied my right to dispute a problem. This resulted from my complete credit report mysteriously vanishing from their system for a period of two months right after I had written critical posts about Experian.

In the above Experian post, there are a total of 42 comments as of today, most of which reference problems with the credit bureau. In each case I provided the FTC online complaint site, and if readers followed through, that is a good start in mounting the drive to bring charges against Experian…again. This is only one blog, and when you search “Experian consumer complaints” on Google blog search, you get almost 4,000 hits. Hopefully many of these blogs are recommending readers complain to the FTC.

As a result of the 1,000 complaints against Academy Collection Services, the Justice Dept. filed a complaint against the company on behalf of the FTC, resulting eventually in the $2.25 million fine against Academy. So just keep this in mind when you are wronged by business, and think you have nowhere to turn. And, hopefully, FTC action against these companies will improve under the Obama administration.

Monday, March 16, 2009


DUMBING DOWN ON PRIVACY


FTC goes commercial to combat misleading Experian free credit report ads. If you haven’t fallen for the FreeCreditReport.com come-on advertised by credit bureau Experian, you’re lucky. As we all know, almost nothing is free anymore, especially in this down economy, and Experian’s ploy is no different. The Philadelphia Inquirer reports on a series of commercials being run by the Federal Trade Commission that announces through Irish step dancers and jamming musicians that this “free” offer has strings attached. You do get a free credit report, but to do so you must sign up for Experian’s credit-monitoring service at $14.95 monthly. Some privacy advocates feel this isn’t made completely clear by the credit bureau. I used to subscribe to Experian’s Credit Manager, and when I did unfavorable posts on Experian, my credit report suspiciously vanished for two months. Coincidence? Actually, the FTC commercials are a parody on the Experian ads which had a budget of $300 million, more than the FTC’s entire budget. If you want the real thing, go to AnnualCreditReport.com. Obama’s stimulus program attracts fraudsters. What else? A down economy, millions out of work, and the scam artists are served up their entrĂ©e in the form of the President’s new stimulus package. The bad guys are coming out of the woodwork promising access to thousands of dollars in government funds, often in the form of grants. PC World says that the U.S. Congress, unintentionally of course, created a cottage industry of Web sites and e-mail spammers to carry out the fraud. Web site PresidentObamaGrants.com sucked in the suckers with a sign-up fee of $2, adding an additional $99 to their credit card if they didn’t cancel within 14 days. Not satisfied, the crooks charged a monthly fee of $49.95, plus $29.95 for a debt-related service, all of which could add up to over $1,000 for a year. Another site, OfficialStimulusGrants.com followed suit, but charging $94.89 each month if the consumer didn’t cancel in a 7 day period. Stealing your money is, of course, the issue, but some are also asking for personal information, which could lead to long-term ID theft. Junk mailers don’t consider consumer privacy a “basic” of marketing. In the March 2009 issue of Direct, a junk mail industry publication, there is an article titled, “Just the Basics.” Taken from a marketing research report prepared by Anderson Analytics, it covers marketers’ concerns for their customers during a recession. Blatantly and astonishingly missing is the security of consumer names and personal data. Don’t know why that surprises me, since during my 35 years as a junk mail list/data broker, it was rare that I could engage clients or large database companies in a conversation about improved protection of customer sensitive data. Here’s the way the report stacks up. First is “customer satisfaction,” followed by “customer retention,” then “ROI,” “brand loyalty,” and a host of other technology concerns that are boring to the average reader. I would give you a link to the site but you have to sign up to access it, a move that might have been prompted by recent criticisms of junk mailers from blogs like The Dunning Letter. There is one highlight, the fact that junk mailers increasingly feel basing marketing functions overseas may not be so good, but still for selfish reasons. They were afraid of the risk, and it wasn’t as profitable. At least they are consistent.

Wednesday, March 11, 2009


NEVER LET YOUR ID GUARD DOWN…NO MATTER WHO SAYS SO


I was rummaging through some older material on identity theft and found an article from the Coalition for Data Security that must have reassured those who think it will never happen to them. First off, I tried to find their Web site but was always directed to a Go Daddy site that does talk about information security, but no coalition. I was shocked to read these three headlines from their article:

• Data security breaches almost never result in identity theft
• Data is often unusable due to encryption
• Consumers are not liable for fraudulent charges

If I were a lay person reading these headlines, I would feel reasonably comfortable that my personal data was completely secure. Of course it isn’t. They even reference Javelin Strategy & Research in the piece; my following comments will also use Javelin in disputing this nonsense. To start, although the article appears to have been done in late 2006 or early 2007, Javelin reported 8.9 million ID theft victims in 2006.

Speaking directly to the three headlines now…

• “Data security breaches almost never result in identity theft” – tell that to the 1,089,000 identity theft victims in 2008 whose data was stolen through data breaches. And that was a 22 percent increase over 2007.

• “Data is often unusable due to encryption” – according to an Identity Theft Resource Center report, only 2.4 percent of 2008 breaches had encryption. Further, Information Security Magazine says that only 22 percent of those recently surveyed by the online magazine planned on including encryption in their budget. Only two states—Nevada and Massachusetts—have laws requiring encryption, but other states have similar measures in the works.

• “Consumers are not liable for fraudulent charges” – sometimes they aren’t, but when they are it is $496 out of their pocket, plus 30 hard hours clearing up their credit problem. Victims’ O-of-P costs in 2008 totaled $4,910,400,000, $540,144,000 for those from data breaches. This also does not include any attorney fees if it is necessary to hire one.


There are other “cutesy” headlines like “The ’Don’t Lose Sleep Over It’ Breach,” which refers to information over which you have no control. Things like your telephone number, your name and address, and public records such as your home value, etc. Actually it won’t do much good to lose sleep over this kind of sensitive data because it is available everywhere. This is due primarily because the junk mail industry realized its value years ago and has since compiled it in to huge databases.

Unfortunately, certain manipulations like adding a date of birth to your name and address can produce disastrous results when it comes to stealing your identity. So, maybe you won’t lose sleep in large part due to the fact that you will check your credit report regularly for fraud. Since you have one free report from each of the credit bureaus—Equifax, TransUnion, Experian—pull one every four months. You’ll be glad you did.

Friday, March 06, 2009


MORE DISTURBING STATS ON ID THEFT…THIS TIME FROM THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION


The FTC has just released their 2009 report on top consumer complaints for the year 2008. For the ninth year in a row, identity theft remains a strong number one with 313,982 complaints representing 26 percent of the total received. Keep in mind: these are actual complaints filed by real victims in incidents of identity theft. In case you aren’t familiar with the procedure, here is the FTC’s site. As you can see, they are fairly thorough in their explanations and instructions to consumers who need help.

I have been told by readers of this blog that the agency is useless in their attempts to solve problems with business or government. To a point, I agree, as do many top privacy advocates. But many of these concerns do stem from the incompetence and/or unwillingness of the Bush administration to do anything for the average consumer.

However, there are two major reasons why you should file a complaint when wronged. First, it goes into reports like the one I am covering here today, and becomes a tool used by the privacy community to convince Congress and the new White House to strengthen privacy law. Second, President Obama has named Jon Leibowitz, an FTC commissioner since 2004, and the lone Democrat on the commission, to serve as FTC Chairman. And yes, that means something, because it has become obvious we cannot depend on the Republican side of the aisle to do anything for the average consumer.

That said, let’s now turn to the FTC’s 2008 Top Consumer Complaints Report.

ID theft was ranked number one for the ninth straight year, receiving 313,982 complaints, representing 26 percent of the total of 1,223,370. Here are the hard facts folks. This is an increase of 21.5 % in identity theft over 2007, with a whopping 50.3% more total complaints registered with the FTC in 2008 over 2007. And here’s another revelation. Complaints against credit bureaus and other data purveyors rose from not even being counted separately in 2007 and 2006 to number six in 2008 with 3 percent of the total. I’d like to think The Dunning Letter, in its coverage of the Experian Credit Bureau’s treatment of consumers, had something to do with this.

The credit bureau entry into the race actually bumped sweepstakes and lotteries into the number seven position, which is significant when you consider the scams in that category. Another “newbie” is banks which are in control of much of our personal financial data, and don’t seem to always realize its value on the Internet black market. Junk mailers, including catalog sales, came in third, and Internet services came in number four.

My next grassroots movement is to convince American consumers they should demand to know everything that is in their credit reports, including any credit scoring techniques, including results, used by business to extend credit. And it should be free every quarter, not once a year, based on the fact that identity theft can happen at any time. Further, individuals should be able to correct their personal information within days, not months or years, as some of my readers have charged in their experiences.

Monday, February 16, 2009


CREDIT CARD SOLICITATIONS GO UNDERGROUND


If your income is less than $100,000 annually, you received 26 percent less credit card offers in 2008, compared to 2007. A prime example of how the junk mail industry manipulates your personal data to maneuver consumers to respond the way they want them to. According to Mintel Comperemedia, who does research for junk mailers, announcing in a ConsumerAffairs report, funds for lending were down, and with the credit card companies already losing on current loans—apparently from those with incomes less than $100,000—they cut mailings back significantly.

Does that halt the barrage on our mailboxes? Not really. They just found another surrogate: businesses you are already dealing with that veil the solicitation under their name, hoping you will make the assumption they endorse the credit card offer. Of course, the business gets a cut from each application returned.

It goes like this. Holland America Line’s headline exclaims: “Presenting the Holland America Line Rewards Visa Card…Your next cruise is closer than you think.” We are cruisers but we have never been on Holland America, so why would I feel any relationship toward them. This is relationship marketing, or affinity, or third party, meaning the company uses their relationship with the customer to sell you something they have absolutely no control over if something goes wrong.

On the other hand, we have been on Princess Cruises, from which we have received two offers in the last couple of weeks. U.S. Airways has hit us twice in the same period of time, and the list goes on. This has been going on in junk mail for at least 35 years, and in bad economic times can be a boon to both of the businesses involved. By sharing the cost of the mailing, or riding piggyback in the company’s regular mail, everyone wins, except the consumer.

I say that because a 2009 survey just released by Javelin Strategy & Research says that 33 percent of the respondents reported that new credit card accounts were opened fraudulently in their name in 2008. That’s an increase of 27 percent over 2007. It only takes the crooks a few minutes on the underground Internet to buy your personal information like Social Security, date of birth, etc., and they are on their way.

You may eventually prove to the credit card provider that you weren’t the bad guys, but you will have a much larger battle convincing the three credit bureaus, Equifax, TransUnion and Experian, to correct your credit history, especially Experian. As an example, the average resolution time to fix your credit in 2008 was 30 hours, up from 26 in 2007.

In the near future I am going to review the complete Javelin 2009 Identity Fraud Survey Report. Here’s a preview of what they found. Identity fraud victims increased 22 percent to 9.9 million in 2008. Economic downturn historically results in increased domestic fraud. Traditional access to private data continues to be commonplace (emphasis added by me). For the consumer version—which I highly recommend reading for some great insights into preventing or dealing with ID theft—go here.

Friday, January 16, 2009


THE TIME HAS COME TO HOLD EXPERIAN ACCOUNTABLE


Most posts in The Dunning Letter result from bringing you current events, with some analysis on how they relate to your privacy. On other occasions, such as today, there is a necessity involved that dictates speaking out. The opportunity that presents itself is one of far-reaching concern over the credit bureau Experian, and its level—or lack of—customer service.

On August 18, 2006, I did a post, “Experian Denies My Right to Dispute Credit Report Problem,” after which I have received a parade of comments (28 to date on just this post), e-mails, and visits to this blog with searches titled “Experian dispute.” Earlier in August of 2006, I had done another post, “Level of Competence at Experian Credit Bureau Found to Be Low,” that documented my personal experience of having my credit report go temporarily missing from the paid service I used, Credit Manager, which normally provided 24/7 access online.

In other words, I had uncovered a rash of complaints against Experian, that did not appear to be anywhere near as prevalent with the other two credit bureaus, Equifax and TransUnion.

Speaking of TransUnion, they had their bout with the government and lost, all the way to the Supreme Court. Back in 1992, the Federal Trade Commission filed suit against TransUnion for selling information that was taken from their consumer credit database. The country’s highest court agreed with the FTC, and the practice was stopped.

But in the last couple of weeks I have received at least five comments, some desperate, accompanied with numerous e-mails, from exasperated victims of Experian’s abominable customer service. I can’t imagine what is taking the FTC so long to take action against this credit bureau; The Dunning Letter, alone, has recommended on numerous occasions that Experian casualties file complaints with the FTC.

I even posed this question with a top privacy advocate who also has no idea how long it will take the agency to wake up. This source does emphasize: always file a complaint because eventually the number will be too large to ignore.

This all brings me to an article I read recently in a junk mail industry publication headlined: “Experian Lays Off 130.” Agreed, this was not the company’s credit bureau operation, but rather the marketing arm for selling their database with well over 200 million consumer names and private information. Things like age, income, whether you drink or gamble, what your ailments are and the medications you take for them. The list goes on numbering hundreds of personal things this company knows about you and sells on a daily basis.

The irony of this is, why couldn’t Experian retrain these people and use them in the credit bureau’s “customer service” department, instead of putting them out of work? Anything would be better than the attention the public is getting now.

Experian’s last reported six month period revenues in 2008 generated $1.04 billion in revenue and $251 million is profit. Total company employees number 15,500, less 130. You’d think out of 15,370 people Experian could find someone to handle you complaint.

Maybe it’s time this action made its way to the Supreme Court.

Friday, June 20, 2008


THE BASIC CASE REHASHED AGAINST JUNK MAILERS WHO SELL YOUR SENSITIVE DATA



Today is my day to jump on the soapbox, and bombard readers with another warning about how your name and sensitive data are collected in an industry where profits rank far above security. Even though it has been said countless times, it deserves another outing, particularly with identity theft still soaring.

If there is one thing that should be remembered by junk mail shoppers, it is that when you order a product or service from a junk mailer, or request information from a non-junk mail company, your name and private information is the real prize in the transaction. Unbeknownst to many consumers, that sensitive data is rushed at lightening speed to a computer facility where it is prepared to be sold, often within 24 hours. Sure, they will deliver your product, or service, or requested information, but that is almost an afterthought to many companies that survive from the marketing of your names and personal data.

And that is not the purpose for which you gave them your name, address, telephone number, credit card account, etc. You gave it to them to deliver what you asked for, not sell it to 50 other junk mailers that, if you should order something from them, will sell it to another 50 companies, and on and on. I also mention non-junk mailers because they are quickly catching up with the traditional list business in collecting names and private information, also putting it up for sale. The most glaring example of this is pharmaceutical companies who buy your prescription data from your local pharmacy.

And the process does not end with the information you provide the junk mailer. Not satisfied, they go to major data brokers like ChoicePoint, Acxiom, Experian, Equifax and TransUnion to enhance the information they already have on you. Things like your age and income, home value, credit cards you carry, children’s names, where you work, what you drink and read, and whether or not you gamble. The last I checked, there were a minimum of 250 known demographic and lifestyle characteristics that could be added to your name and address.

There are now around 60,000 lists on the market that gross over $4 billion each year by the junk mail list industry. Most of these lists are not regulated by the Direct Marketing Assn. (DMA), so they are free to do what they please with your name and personal data. Most are honest, but it is the group of renegades that will sell your private information to unethical and dishonest companies that ply us with fraudulent offers, then vanish into the night.

Selling mailing lists has created a life of its own, and with the way new technology is evolving, every day there are new ways to suck up every morsel of private information available on each of us. Although I cannot confirm this, I bet that there is a new database filled with consumer sensitive data born every hour. Maybe even more often. Question if you will, but we have entered the age of Orwell’s Big Brother.

Friday, May 30, 2008


ACXIOM PROVIDES BUSINESS NEW AUTHENTICATION OF ONLINE CUSTOMERS. BUT, HOW ACCURATE IS IT?


Junk mail data broker, Acxiom, has just announced that it will introduce a new service, FactCheck-X Authenticate, to business clients based on unique biographically based questions asked of online customers that are designed to qualify them with the company they are contacting. This could be logging into your stock portfolio, accessing your bank statements, or perhaps even looking at your medical records. In an article on PR-inside.com, “businesses are more secure and customers can experience a better online authentication experience.” I doubt the latter, and here’s the reason why.

In 2005—and if anyone finds a later report please let me know—the non-profit Privacy Activism did a study to determine the accuracy of biographical information in two major data brokers, Acxiom and ChoicePoint. Acxiom’s authentication, above, is based on biographical data. It was discovered that even in the most basic information like name, address, phone number, Social Security number, errors were found in 67 percent of Acxiom’s reports. If this has been corrected, I welcome factual substantiation that it has.

NewsEnet.com provides insight into some of those biographical questions inquiring consumer minds might be faced with.

• In what subdivision do you live?

• Where does your brother Mike live?

• Select a state which you were previously licensed to drive.

• How many fireplaces are in your current residence?

OK, what if both Mike and I just moved? Will Acxiom allow for this mistake, and then ask where the former residences were? The fact that they are asking anything about my driver’s license bothers me, but I guess telling them about my fireplace won’t hurt.

Jennifer Barrett, Acxiom’s chief privacy officer, won’t reveal specific sources of your biographical data, but adds that it did come from “public document files and private sources.” She also cites the Patriot Act as a crutch for doing this, which immediately throws up warning flags and reminders of NSA’s warrantless spying. Lee Tien of non-profit Electronic Frontier Foundation sees no advantage to the service. Others can find out many of these facts about you, and her opinion is that a random, newly assigned PIN would be safer.

I did a post in February of this year where it is shown how your name and personal information are eternalized—similar to your name and date of passing on your tombstone—in data broker databanks across this country and throughout the world. The major companies responsible for collecting your private information and archiving it forever are Experian, TransUnion, Equafax, ChoicePoint, and of course Acxiom. The first three are also credit bureaus, holding your most precious credit data as well.

In March of 2007, another post was done on Acxiom’s new connection to May Company stores, which were eventually converted to Macy’s. Acxiom was enhancing the Macy’s list—including Bloomingdale’s, also a part of Federated Stores—with customer personal data, among which is your age, income, plus a number of other demographic characteristics, then purchase and lifestyle behavior like health interests, religion, credit cards held, politics, cell phone owners, investments, reading and vacation habits, and wine drinkers. If you are a Macy’s or Bloomingdale’s card holder—there are over 3.6 million—go to this site to see what all they know about you.

So the next time you shop at Macy’s or Bloomingdale’s online, they might ask you if you have arthritis, or if you like baseball, if you are on a diet, what shape your houseplants are in, or how was your recent skiing trip? If you can’t answer the questions, don’t be surprised if they hesitate to sell you a collar for your cat, which they already know you own.

Monday, May 19, 2008


HOW LONG BEFORE WE ACCEPT INEVITABILITY OF PERSONAL HEALTH RECORDS DATABASES?


The jury is still out but the heat is still on to collect and computerize our personal health records (PHRs). One opinion has it that benefits will “eclipse” privacy concerns. And with certain reservations, I agree. As staunch as I am for individual rights to control our names and private information, if you are in the hospital emergency room with a family member, you want them to receive the best possible care, and most agree that can happen only if the caregivers know the patient’s personal health history.

Jay Cline’s opinion piece in Computerworld, “Benefits of personal health records will eclipse privacy concerns,” makes a good case, concluding that the debate will be over in five years, but many privacy advocates who actually anticipate the inevitability, still want to see better control. Over both the PHR providers and by the individual concerned. Cline says there will be six prevailing stipulations of this kind of database.

• A single repository combing multiple sources.
• Simplified, easily searchable files.
• Doctor’s trust
• Understandable to the patient.
• Patient can add and flag incorrect information
• Patient controls who sees what

But when he gets to what will be included in the database, he makes the statement that, “The sky is really the limit…” And to me that is really scary, because that is how the junk mail companies like ChoicePoint, Experian, Acxiom, Equifax, TransUnion and other data brokers started years ago. With your name and address, and a few other items like age, income, education and occupation. That eventually expanded into what we read, drink and smoke, and whether or not we gamble. Who we vote for, what our religion is, our surfing habits online, the charities we favor, how we invest, and of course the precursor to today’s subject, what ailments we have and what medications we take. Yes, it’s all out there and for sale.

Promised data to the PHRs contains the following: prescriptions; drug allergies; immunizations; illnesses and hospitalizations; test and clinical records; living wills and other info you can see by going to the Computerworld article in the above link. I did a series of five posts you might want to refer to on this issue: “Medical Identity Theft Also Needs Your Attention…And Now.” It provides the background on what can happen when the bad guys steal your medical identity, and why it is so important for this private information to be protected.

In another of my posts, “Warning Out on Health Data Storage Sites,” there is a report issued by the World Privacy Forum in February of 2008 about the hazards of giving up your personal health records. The catch, according to the WPF, is that most of these companies are not subject to federal regulations relating to consumer privacy and security. It is for that very reason that I feel the right solution is only one database—as Cline specifies—operated by a non-commercial entity, with its own set of privacy rules backed by federal enforcement.

Next post: How the U.S. must take its privacy guidelines, even in healthcare, from the European Union.

Thursday, April 17, 2008


DUMBING DOWN ON PRIVACY


LifelLock, the identity protection company whose CEO, Todd Davis, flaunts his Social Security number before the public to prove that his service works, is being sued in a class-action suit. The litigation alleges deceptive marketing, according to Reuters.com, and comes less than two months after the Experian Credit Bureau sued LifeLock for false advertising. See my Feb. 25 post. The New Jersey Pasternack family who filed the suit says LifeLock “misled them about the limited level of identity protection the company provides, and failed to warn them about the potential adverse impact those services could have on their credit profiles.” The complaint adds that Davis’ style of advertising “lulls” potential subscribers into a false sense of security by misrepresenting the degree of protection they will receive. The company charges $10.00 a month for services that consumers can do on their own free of charge. Maybe if we get these people fighting among themselves, Congressional leaders will finally realize that something needs to be done, and now. South Carolina decides to get tough with identity theft by passing a stringent law to better protect its citizens. The state becomes one of only two stipulating that residents can place or lift security freezes on their credit reports at no charge, based on a report in the SC Morning News. Additions to the bill include penalties for credit bureaus who don’t correct incorrect information, and a 15-minute lift on a credit report freeze with the consumer’s pin number. States continue to show the federal government how to do it, but an inept Congress can’t see the breaches for the business lobbyists. In another state, Colorado, Jefferson County DA, Scott Storey, also understands the identity crisis and is doing something about it. Based on a piece in YourHub.com, Storey’s fraud alert team is advising consumers to buy a paper shredder, the diamond cut kind which is supposed to be the best. Colorado ranks eighth in the U.S. for ID theft, which is apparently enough to get this DA to start an awareness campaign that is sorely needed across the country. He shows the county residents just how the crooks do it by exposing methods like fake driver’s licenses or chemically altered checks. A local project director for crime prevention, Cary Johnson, holds seminars on the subject and makes an excellent point. The crooks know our lifestyle habits, like writing a check and putting it in the local neighborhood postal box. He also made the comment that, based on Federal Trade Commission statistics indicating that 5 percent of Americans become victims of identity theft each year, in the next ten years 50 percent of the U.S. population will have succumbed. The junk mail whiners are at it again. They are questioning the motives of a New Hampshire state representative who introduced a bill to establish a statewide do-not-call registry on behalf of those who find unsolicited mail intrusive. I looked up “intrusive” on Dictionary.com and found the following definition: “tending or apt to intrude; coming without invitation or welcome.” If that isn’t the perfect description of junk mail, I don’t know what is. The industry article says junk mailers find it “mystifying” why Rep. Suzi Nord would call their work intrusive. After spending 35 years in the business as a junk mail list/data broker, I find it exasperating that these people cannot figure out that when 98 percent of what they produce goes in the trash, what is it if not junk? The feds are still not addressing the problems that caused data breaches like the 26.5 million records lost by the Veterans Administration. MSNBC says that the General Accounting Office has found that most of the two dozen federal agencies examined still haven’t initiated five federal recommendations to protect private information. Eighteen other agencies had complied “to varying degrees.” This is important to the American public because over 20 percent of all data breaches originate in the government sector. We certainly won’t see much shoring up of this issue by the Bush administration, and it is beginning to look like the Democrats have put consumerism on the back burner, perhaps for the upcoming election. It seems to me that the timing is perfect for an Independent candidate to step in and show that he or she will put consumers out front again. Go to Committee for a Unified Independent Party (CUIP) for more on the Independent movement. Any suggestions for candidates?

Thursday, March 27, 2008


MEDICAL IDENTITY THEFT ALSO NEEDS YOUR ATTENTION…AND NOW – PART 4


The article by Arian Eigen Heald, “’Medical’ Identity Theft – New (to me) and Scary,” explains her dilemma, but what is scary to me is that it is “new” to her, an expert in her field of computer technology. Heald has served as a systems engineer, network administrator, webmistress, and a number of other positions related to the Internet and computers for years. So, if medical identity theft is new to her, we have done one lousy job of getting this fraud before the public, even professionals. And that is the answer and the reason for this series of posts on the subject. Part 3, yesterday, covered a couple of bizarre incidents in Florida where millions of dollars were stolen by crooks. We closed by covering an article voicing privacy advocates’ concerns over the latest rush to build personal health record (PHR) databases by Microsoft and Google, and my promise to illustrate how we might make this all work. See Part 1, Part 2. Picking up again on the Washington Post article quoted from yesterday, Deborah Peel, a Texas psychiatrist and founder of the non-profit, Patient Privacy Rights, “wants Americans to retain exclusive control over their medical records.” Now there is an idea I can get behind 100 percent. Although Microsoft has said they won’t, Peel thinks that the information given to the PHRs would be shared with data mining companies, and could end up being sold to insurance companies and on the open list market. And she is exactly right, based on my 35 years as a list/data broker and database consultant. In addition, PHRs are not covered by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). The excitement over public health record databases by the MSs and Googles is beginning to sound like the frenzy in the junk mail list business years ago when they first realized they had personal consumer data to sell like your telephone number and date of birth. This has escalated today into humongous databases with private information on millions of Americans, including up to 250 personal identification characteristics about each individual. The leaders are ChoicePoint, Acxiom, Experian, Equifax and TransUnion, the latter three also being credit bureaus. Sidney Wolfe, director of Public Citizen’s Health Research Group says that no matter how secure the PHRs think they are, it only takes one insider to steal the information and sell it to insurers or employers. It seems that, since the identity crisis was officially put in motion in early 2005 by the ChoicePoint breach, before we can solve one problem—like financial identity theft—another hot potato surfaces…like medical ID theft. Business, government and the Congress have been skirting the issue since it became apparent this crime was not only here to stay, but seems to get worse every year. In three years of blogging on The Dunning Letter, I have held to one concept that I feel sure will solve the identity theft dilemma. Give consumers control over their names and personal data, and compensate them when it is sold as an extra incentive to take over this responsibility. Deborah Peel is a force behind this philosophy in relation to medical data, and it is time the general public got behind the both of us.

Wednesday, March 19, 2008


PROBLEMS WITH EXPERIAN CREDIT BUREAU HIGHEST SEARCH TOPIC ON THE DUNNING LETTER


Of all the information available on The Dunning Letter that readers could search for, problems with the Experian Credit Bureau—particularly not being able to file a dispute or not being able to even contact the company—top the list. And this doesn’t even include general searches like “credit bureau dispute.” This has been going on since I posted on the fact that my Experian credit report—a report I paid $90 yearly to access—vanished from the system and didn’t return for two months. No explanation, zilch. Links to four posts: one, two, three, four. This all happened mysteriously after I had done some posts on Experian in my blog with unfavorable comments. Not that this was the reason, but, as they say, very coincidental. In addition, there were heated comments to the post links, above, from readers that seemed to be at the end of their rope and ready to pounce on the next person that got in their way. All because of a lack of response from Experian to real problems experienced by these consumers. Based on these experiences, and because ConsumerAffairs.com does such a good job of documenting complaints against the three credit bureaus, I have decided to post regularly on the latest updates, bringing you the current status on problems with these agencies. In future articles I will also report on how consumers are dealing with this dilemma, and link to authoritative sites that provide advice on how to deal with any situation where credit bureaus balk at responding and/or legally following up on complaints. In this first post, Experian will be featured, but the other two credit bureaus, Equifax and TransUnion, will be covered at a later date. Now to the horror stories. There have been 12 of these since the beginning of 2008, all documented on ConsumerAffairs.com Experian Complaints. New Jersey man reports Experian’s refusal to provide free credit reports, after insurance company breached personal data. Bank account frozen due to opening of bogus accounts. New York disabled person puts daughter on credit card account. E transferred his HSBC debt (financial institution with most FTC complaints) to her name and refuses to correct. E would not communicate. Man contacted state Attorney General and got results. Texas disputed inaccurate item, and when E refused to remove, he threatened to sue. He was blocked from credit report, suffered rude treatment. A Chapter 7 bankruptcy wrongfully ends up on Florida’s credit causing score to drop 100 points. E will not respond, cannot get a human on phone. Lost a mortgage on his first home. California received a letter from E stating “someone” had requested change in couple’s names/address and Social Security numbers, but would offer no additional info. After providing copies of passports, driver’s licenses, mortgage statement, and pay stubs, E wanted more identification. Filed complaint with ConsumerAffairs.com. Michigan sent letter with documentation to dispute negative items to E’s president, Kerry Williams, who refused to investigate. Tennessee is in a two year battle with E over credit report problems. Equifax and TransUnion made necessary changes requested, but E continues to be a “nightmare.” To contact Experian, here is the address and telephone number: Experian, P.O. Box 2002, Allen, TX 75013, 1 888 397 3742. If you have the same problems as others have reported, above, I suggest you file complaints with your state attorney general, the FTC, and ConsumerAffairs.com. Good luck!

Monday, February 25, 2008


EXPERIAN CREDIT BUREAU SUES LIFELOCK FOR FALSE ADVERTISING – NOW THAT’S THE EPITOME OF THE POT CALLING THE KETTLE BLACK


Back in August of 2005, the Federal Trade Commission settled a case with Experian Consumer Direct, a subsidiary of the credit bureau, for deception in advertising “free credit reports” by failing to add the customer would be automatically signed up for credit monitoring services costing $79.95 each year. The FTC ordered Experian to give up $950,000 of its “ill-gotten gains. I posted on a personal incident with Experian about a year after this action in which my credit report vanished from the system for a period of two months after I posted some unfavorable comments about the company in my blog, with no explanation from Experian when it mysteriously reappeared. Article one and two. Coincidence or not, I had no record of my credit during that period. Following my first post on this incident, which explained my experience with an Experian customer service department that was completely incompetent, there were 47 comments supporting my findings. Since then, one of the top search engine search topics to my blog has been the problems readers have had with Experian. So now they are at the receiving end and don’t seem to like it. Experian is suing LifeLock, according to one of my favorite blogs, Pogo Was Right, alleging it is losing “millions of dollars a year because of LifeLock’s ‘illegal and fraudulent activities.’” Here’s a copy of the complaint, compliments of Pogo. Experian also claims it suffers a huge expense operating toll-free lines to process fraud alerts for thousands of LifeLock customers. My experience with their toll-free telephone numbers is that, either you can never reach a human being, or, if you do, they are clueless about how to help you. And then there’s the false advertising claim against LifeLock that makes the lawsuit seem like an overblown act of hypocrisy. Don’t get me wrong. I do not believe in paying for identity theft protection that any individual can do free. Aside from the fact that the protection is limited, some companies in this business never deliver what you pay for. There was an offer recently from my U.S. Airways Dividend Miles club for LifeLock, where I can get from 250 to 1000 miles to sign up. Although this may not be a direct endorsement by the airline, it looks like it is, and will be taken by many of its members as a recommendation for the service. In another article on MSNBC, it is reported that LifeLock has 700,000 customers that pay $120 per year for their service. This translates into $84,000,000 in the pockets of the company, most of which results from scare tactics in the media and in advertising, and an unending quest by consumers for “convenience.” On that one word was the junk mail industry built. In the MSNBC piece, Experian contends that LifeLock is no protection against theft already in progress, and in many cases is unable to stop undocumented workers from ripping off you Social Security number to get a job. Are you ready yet to support my grass roots effort to grant consumers control over their names and personal data?

Wednesday, February 20, 2008


MAILING LISTS ARE ETERNAL…INCLUDING YOUR PERSONAL DATA


Periodically I cover junk mail lists on the market with attention directed to those that contain the most private information about the individual. I point these lists out to you because you should know who is keeping tabs on your daily activities and lifestyle habits. There is one thing that I can guarantee about these lists, and that is…your name, address and sensitive data will probably outlive you. One such list is AmeriLINK from KnowledgeBase Marketing, which professes to have private information on 230 million individuals nationwide. That’s about 76 percent of the total population, and they aren’t even one of the big-five consumer database companies (Equifax, Experian, TransUnion, ChoicePoint and Acxiom). They are big enough to have collected and made available for sale a wealth of information on most of the American public. Facts like your household income, your date of birth, your net worth, your telephone number, all arranged conveniently with your name and address. It’s the kind of data ID thieves would kill for. But that’s not all. For 45 million of you, there is voting data indicating your party preference. They know what credit cards you carry, and when you opened these accounts. That info isn’t as significant as the fact that the credit card company gave it up specifying you as the holder. And one of my biggest concerns in this area is the selling of your medical ailments. This covers most all the cancers, high blood pressure and cholesterol, diabetes, heart disease, including heart attacks, Alzheimer’s disease, erectile dysfunction, depression, lung disease, and the list goes on and on. The release of this kind of data, which points right to the individual, raises all kinds of privacy flags when it comes to applying for health insurance or for a job. Yes, you must be honest with potential insurers or employers, but my concern is the amount of potential inaccurate data in these lists. In a study by non-profit, Privacy Activism, they found errors—Including name, address, Social Security number—in 67 percent of background reports from Acxiom, 73 percent from ChoicePoint. If you smoke, drink or gamble, someone can buy this information, along with the fact that you travel frequently. If you have taken an equity loan on your house, the original purchase amount, who owns the property, the lender’s name, interest rate and loan type, along with the mortgage term are recorded, ready for sale. If you move, what kind of house you moved from and to, the distance of the move, and the new and previous address. They have a list of “attitude” categories from “adventure seekers” to “youth chasers.” And then some quirky selects like “I am at capacity,” “I am down to earth,” and “I am devoted,” which are results of combining all your demographic and lifestyle data and through computer modeling, predict what your core values are. This last one gets creepy, and smacks of Big Brother. In the case with companies like AmeriLINK, you just have to hope they have data breach security in place, and that all employees are honest and aware of the potential of information loss. On the other hand, we could grant consumers control over their names and personal data which would insure this security. AmeriLINK and other junk mail list companies like them could still sell our private information, but with the consumer’s finger on the approval button, and aware of any transaction using their personal data. The real upside of this move is that identity theft could probably be eliminated.

Thursday, February 14, 2008


CHUTZPAH OR ARROGANCE. YOU DECIDE


In a December 2007 article from Multichannel Merchant by Denise Hopkins, she documents how data collectors can turn your innocent credit card purchase into a treasure trove of valuable information in the form of appending additional personal data. Hopkins is the vice president of marketing and product development for Experian Marketing Services, one of the top five consumer database companies, and top three credit bureaus in the country. The reason that it is important to spend this extra money to better identify you is that one-third of all consumer purchases are with credit cards, amounting to $40 out of each $100 spent. The Experian VP states that the customer is already aware of the company’s “brand,” with the implication that this makes building a profile of the individual OK. It is not! What it is is a sneak attack through the back door building a dossier on this person who has no inclination of what is going on. Although there is no mention of selling this information—in junk mail circles when you buy something from one of these companies, that usually translates into the right for them to sell your name and personal data—and that is the business of the Experian Marketing Services division. As a former list broker, I bought lists from them for years. You can, of course, opt out of the sale of your sensitive data but in Hopkins’ process, this is an afterthought. She even gives a blueprint of how to pull off the caper. You lift the information from the magnetic strip on the back of the card, which normally includes the card holder’s name and address. Then, proceed to the third party data service—which Experian provides—to append the extra juicy stuff like your age, income, occupation, education, home value, and the list goes on and on. They even know if you gamble, drink, smoke and have your medical ailments and prescriptions taken. Denise Hopkins may not have had any of the scenarios I have created here in mind. What I can assure you is that it is all possible—and with the junk mail industry committed to collecting and selling every morsel of private consumer information they can get their hands on—it is also likely. So you tell me. Is it chutzpas or arrogance? Or have junk mailers really convinced themselves that they own our names and personal data, and may do with them exactly as they please? I believe it is the latter. See more posts on Experian here, here and here.

Friday, November 16, 2007


IT’S FRIDAY MORNING. DO YOU KNOW WHERE YOUR NAME IS?


With over 50,000 lists on the market being sold hourly by the junk mail industry, I feel it is important that you know something about the kinds of lists where you might find your name and private information. Until consumers are granted control over this sensitive data, there is really nothing you can do to prevent its sale, except put your name on the Direct Marketing Assn.’s (DMA) “Mail Preference List (MPL),” and the FTC’s “Do-Not-Call” list for telephone solicitation. The FTC’s DNC list seems to be working, but I am not so sure of the DMA’s MPS, based on reactions of people who are on it. Besides, the FTC requires all telemarketers to use the DNC, but the DMA’s control over use of the MPS list is limited to their membership. However, some large and well-known junk mailers are not even members, as well as hundreds of smaller companies. When I was still working as a list/data broker, I even ran into the head of a computer processing facility who recommended mailing the Mail Preference List to his clients; the reasoning was these people were receiving very little mail by being on the list. He was also a member of the DMA. This will become a regular feature of The Dunning Letter, based on lists that are applicable. To start, there is a new list by the name of “America’s Wireless/Cell Phone Owners With Opt-In E-Mail Addresses,” that claims to have a universe of over 103 million. You have given this list owner the right to sell your name for e-mail advertising and for telemarketing, and you have identified your wireless carrier. In addition to normal junk mail marketing, the list is being recommended for debt collections and skip tracing; the latter being a method to harvest an individual’s personal data. They know your age, the age of your children, date of birth, income and your lifestyle habits. Next is the “Consumers With High FICO Scores” list which reflects your credit score used for applying for mortgages or other means of credit. There are 431,000 individuals captured from—and this comes straight from the list owner—credit applications you made for high dollar, re-finance or mortgage loans, sold to them by the three credit bureaus, Experian, Equifax and TransUnion. The list is broken down by the typical FICO ratings of 800+, 750-799, 700-749, and 661-699. By the way, they also have a list of those of you with low FICO scores starting with 650 down. I can see a potential problem of “low scores” getting in the wrong hands, since restraints on renting this list would probably be much less stringent than obtaining your FICO score from the credit bureaus. And finally, the “Revolution Automotive Data” list. Take away one source for names, and junk mailers will always find a new one. This was the case when a law prompted by the shooting death of actress Rebecca Schaeffer in 1989, was passed in 1994 preventing states from selling motor vehicle records. Schaeffer’s killer obtained her address from the California Dept. of Motor Vehicles. The law was the “Driver’s Privacy and Protection Act of 1994,” which virtually closed down a complete division of R.L. Polk which compiled and sold the list. The list contains more than 25 million names with the type vehicle owned from Acura to Volvo, including your name/address, telephone number and e-mail address. They also know your age, income and lifestyle habits. It is my opinion as a former list/data broker for 35 years that there are some lists you may choose to be on because you want the latest gardening or apparel catalogs, but there are some you probably don’t want to be on. My guess is the above three fit in the latter category.

Saturday, November 03, 2007


CREDIT BUREAUS, DATA BREACH LEGISLATION AND MISSED OPPORTUNITIES


New York Senator Charles Schumer, a Democrat, just threatened legislative action if credit bureaus make consumers pay for credit freezes. The big three credit bureaus, Experian, Equifax and TransUnion are charging $10 each, thus, a total of $30 to cover all three, according to junk mail publication, DM News. OK, let’s do some math. Remember ChoicePoint—it’s almost as familiar as "Remember the Alamo" these days—and their breach of 163,000 individual records back in February of 2005? This was a result of Nigerian ID thieves heisting the sensitive data for the purpose of stealing consumers’ identities, resulting in potentially 3,800 victims of ID theft based on FTC figures. Our first mathematical equation multiplies 163,000 times $30.00 equaling $4,890,000, which is the amount paid by Consumers and revenue received by credit bureaus for credit freezes in just the ChoicePoint breach. The second equation which multiplies 3,800 times $5,720 (fraud amount lost per victim) equals $21,736,000 total victim loss just for the CP breach. So the American consumer who did absolutely nothing wrong in this incident ends up spending a total of $26,626,000 for future protection, and to clean up someone else’s mess. Pathetic. And on the legislative front, the data breach Bobsy Twins, Senators Patrick Leahy and Arlen Specter, have introduced yet another bill, the Identity Theft Enforcement and Restitution Act, which would allow consumers to seek relief from costs involved in an identity theft. (See article) How many times have we been to this well before with no results? Leahy and Specter appear to have the consumer’s best interest at heart, but they can never get the job done, and that is the history of the U.S. Congress we are saddled with now. The author of the arstechnica.com piece above relates to William Faulkner in describing the issue. He confirms that congressional leaders do make a lot of noise over the problem, but he adds: “Unfortunately for residents of the US, the legislative branch of our government has proven itself to be full of sound and fury, signifying nothing when it comes to this issue.” Very well said. Now, how many of you have heard that an appeals court has dismissed a lawsuit that would have compensated certain data breach victims? Affected would be those who have not actually suffered economic harm from the breach, but who had to spend time and money, like credit monitoring or freezes, to prevent potential losses. It was class action litigation against Old Nat’l Bancorp. which operates a Web site for individuals looking for financial services. The data breached from Bancorp.’s hosting facility was name/address, Social Security number, driver’s license number, date of birth, mother’s maiden name and some other financial account information. What more could ID thieves ask for? The Seventh Circuit Court in its decision said that emotional damages suffered over the breach weren’t actual out of pocket losses, thus, they didn’t count. I have talked to one very sharp legal mind that doesn’t necessarily agree with this assumption. However, the problem rests with the Indiana law on which the case is based. The court says basically that the state law, as it is written, did not intend for this type of victim to have a cause of action against the breaching company. Just another example of weak state law when it comes to the identity crisis and another missed opportunity for the consumer.

Friday, October 05, 2007


BUSINESS AND GOVERNMENT STILL MANIPULATE YOUR NAMES AND PERSONAL DATA AT THEIR PLEASURE


The ACLU is demanding that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) shut down the illegal Automated Targeting System (ATS) because it violates a congressional mandate barring DHS from assigning risk levels to innocent Americans, using personal data through data-mining techniques. The program was “approved without public or congressional consideration,” according to an ACLU release. And then a Newsweek article trumpets the fact that computer data-mining technology is replacing human intuition in deciding what you plan to buy, or just what book you will read next. All of this has been going on for years in both the private sector and federal agencies. I can account for over 20 years of tracking consumer whereabouts during my 35 years as a junk mail data broker and database consultant. We wanted to know everything about you and on a regular basis found new ways to dig up your private information and maneuver it through the system to track your daily habits. But the grind goes on and there was a distressing announcement in September by ComputerWorld.com of a story by the New York Times that MySpace was outdoing Google in the collecting and using of your personal data. Blogger Preston Gralla says the NYT reports that MySpace will use 100 employees “to grab every piece of personal information it can about its users, and then use that to finely target ads.” This reeks of the old junk mail entrepreneurs who collected every morsel of your sensitive data, promptly deemed it their property, and then eventually sold it to the tune of what is today $4 billion annually. Gralla says of MySpace, “[Collecting] may be just the beginning. Will sales of that data be far behind?” Returning to government activity, the Washington Post had a good article in 2006 how the feds were “increasingly turning to data-mining.” First off, they go to the junk mail industry for consumer information; companies like ChoicePoint, Acxiom and LexisNexis. Other consumer database companies loaded with your private information are Experian, Equifax and TransUnion, all three of which are also credit bureaus. These six companies, themselves, engage in individual household data-mining at the highest levels, including neural network predictive modeling, also known as artificial intelligence. The NSA spying episode brought to light the government’s interest in your telephone activity, using databases provided by the private sector. WP states it is hard to pinpoint how many such data contracts exist, but points out 52 government agencies had launched or had plans for at least 199 data-mining projects as far back as 2004. Data-mining, or predictive modeling as some refer to it, was a blip on the horizon when I became involved some 20 years ago in junk mail. I’ve watched the technology develop over the years into something that, in the right hands, can be used as a surveillance tool that can tell you things about yourself even you don’t know. It’s done by combining personal data with sophisticated algorithms that analyze trends that can be used to make uncanny predictions. There was a great quote in the Federal Times by Tim Grance, manager of the National Institute of Standards and Technology’s computer security division: “Developing policy is easy,” he said. But, he added: “God and the devil both dwell in the implementation.” Think the Bush administration will ever figure this one out?

Thursday, October 04, 2007


MY LATEST STROLL DOWN "PERSONAL DATA BREACH" MEMORY LANE


It is my practice to let the personal data breaches pile up, and then I cull out the most significant of the bunch and report them to you, just in case you may have missed these important incidents. This time I go back to June of this year and the theft of a storage device from an Ohio government intern’s car with 64,000 state employees’ personal information including Social Security numbers. (See Story) But according to a story in The Columbus Dispatch, the significance of the occurrence was downplayed from the beginning. Ohio Republicans called it a “cover-up” since Gov. Ted Strickland is a Democrat. Next, there were the computers stolen from the Yale College Dean’s office in July, compromising the names and Social Security numbers of 10,000 current and former students, faculty and staff. The Yale Daily News reported “The lost files had not been maintained for any purpose,” and “were overlooked in the University’s efforts at reducing the amount of personal information it holds.” Just when you thought you’d heard it all. Approximately 25 percent of all data breaches nationwide happen in places of higher learning, which qualifies this area as critical in the identity crisis. And then came Certegy’s breach of 8.5 million customer checking account and credit card records, also in July. I did two posts on this you can read here and here. Certegy is a subsidiary of Fidelity National Information Services, a financial processing company that provides solutions supporting financial services companies throughout the world. It is alleged that a senior employee by the name of William G. Sullivan heisted the records and sold them through a company he owned to junk mailers. This is a case of companies buying consumers’ sensitive data without checking its source, and from my experience as a junk mail data broker, that is irresponsible. But here is the most bazarre case I have heard of in a long time. The Russian connection targets wealthy Americans with high home equity loan reserves, and has stolen $1.5 million from their accounts with attempts to steal another $10.7 million, according to Technology News Daily. The conspiracy ringleader is a 24 year old Russian named Igor Klopov from Moscow who scammed, among others, the head of a major credit reporting agency. He had four accomplices spread out all over the country, all of which have now been indicted as of August 17. Maybe now we can get the attention of the Experian, Equifax, and TransUnion people, but I won’t hold my breath. It sounds like a James Bond novel with the likes of the US Secret Service, NYPD, and the Manhattan district Attorney’s Identity Theft Unit involved. One bright spot in the scam was JP Morgan/Chase bank’s alertnertness that stopped one of the transactions before the money was taken. Johns Hopkins Hospital in Maryland had a computer stolen in July with over 5 thousand patients’ names, SS#s, birth dates, medical histories, and other personal information, as reported by the Baltimore Sun. It took more than five weeks before the victims were alerted of the theft. The University of Kansas apparently not very vigilant in disposing of personal records containing SS#s, addresses, insurance details and student grades. The U. newspaper the Kansan says in their September story that no less than four other breaches have occurred. The Gap had 800,000 job applicant personal records including SS#s and other private information taken in the theft of a laptop from a third-party vendor in September, says MSNBC.com. Other Gap stores include Old Navy, banana Republic, and Outlet stores in Puerto Rico and Canada. But the prize-winner is the alleged charge by an attorney that Ameritrade online brokerage lost personally identifying information to hackers for some 6.3 million customers. The class-action lawsuit filed last May against the company also aleges it knew of the breach a year ago (last November), but kept pumping user information into the breached database. The story appeared on InformationWeek.com on September 17, 2007, and quotes security company Sophos as warning Ameritrade users “to be on ‘red alert’ against targeted spam attacks.” Personal data taken was names, e-mail addresses, phone numbers and home addresses. By masquerading as Ameritrade, the phishing underground could have a field-day with this one.

Saturday, September 29, 2007


DUMBING DOWN ON PRIVACY


Junk mailers need more honesty in their editorializing. That’s my answer to an editorial in the junk mail industry publication, DM News, with the headline “Consumers need more data knowledge” by Eleanor Trickett, Ed. In Chief. In the first sentence she cites “government laptops stolen,” but fails to mention the breach by junk mail data broker ChoicePoint, which put this whole identity theft issue in motion. She proceeds to talk about how much information consumers are asked to give up for the sake of convenience or a discount, but completely skirts the fact that junk mailers are the ones to blame for this insane drive to find out everything there is to know about every individual in the US. Just once I would like to see these people come right out and say, “This identity crisis is all our fault, and it’s time we did something to stop it.” Yeah. That’ll be the day. Junk mailers are lobbying their way out of federal legislation they don’t want and the consumer is the loser. It’s so obvious by the fact there isn’t one piece of data breach legislation that is close to becoming a law. CNNMoney.com did a recent piece on ChoicePoint’s lobbying expenditures: $500,000 in just the first half of 2007. I figured if CP was doing this, other junk mail data brokers couldn’t be far behind. I was so right. OpenSecrets.org is a great site to find things that business and government would rather you didn’t know. I went to their Lobbying Database and this is what I found on the top data brokers and credit bureaus: Acxiom spent $160,000; Lexis Nexis $40,000, their parent, Reed Elsevier, $3,380,000; Experian $300,000; Equifax $100,000; and TransUnion $80,000. Experian, Equifax and TransUnion are credit bureaus, as well as maintaining huge consumer databases chock full of personal data as well. You have to wonder what all this money buys, but a quick guess would be favorable data breach legislation, or none at all. Phishing just got more sophisticated, and they’re taking on the GOV. The latest uses an IRS front to contact someone offering a tax refund, for which you have to give up private information, of course. According to ZDNet.com, the bad guys send thousands of e-mails that in many cases are hard to differentiate from the real thing. So much so, 8.2 percent of online households have taken the bait losing an estimated $630 million. The Government Accountability Office (GAO) puts the figure at $1 billion annually. Most people hate statistics but you’d better pay attention to these, because they have the potential for significant growth, considering the number of federal agencies that deal with the public. This is a trend, folks, and it isn’t going away. It will only get worse unless you join my grass-roots movement to grant consumers control over their names and personal data, with compensation to the name-holder when it is sold. Let me hear from you!